Quote From: julie1418Crime and bullying do NOT come from the public school system. We don't teach that as a special elective class! LOL! Crime and bullying come from people - and from kids. It's not inherent to the institution of public schools. Just because public schools have to deal with the problems of undisciplined children doesn't mean they are the CAUSE of those problems.
While I do not argue that private schooling or even homeschooling may be the best choice for some families, I am a bit concerned over the idea that just any parent is qualified to educate his/her children. It is a VERY serious commitment that requires time, dedication, and ability. I cannot tell you how many children are returned to public schools after parents get bored with homeschooling, and the children are woefully behind not only in academics but in social skills.
I know there are many homeschooling success stories, but I think it is misleading to say that any parent will be able to be successful in this area. Some simply do not have the ability, the education, the time, or a full understanding of what is required. I disagree that EVERY parent knows what is best for his/her child. If that were true, we wouldn't have the problems we have today. I know a lot of great parents, but I also have met many who absolutely SHOULD NOT homeschool.
I don't take exception to your post.
However, as a certified high school teacher (who taught for 9 years), I take exception to your conclusion that public school teachers are more educated to teach than everyone else. I have worked with MANY lousy public school teachers. Some didn't want to teach, but wanted summers off (etc). Some were teaching out of field (ex. a PE teacher trying to teach upper level math). Some couldn't be fired because of tenure and a teachers' union that protected every the lousiest of teacher!
A degree does not mean anything. My good friend homeschools and she does not have a college education. However, she loves kids, is very bright (gifted), is extremely resourceful and puts her ALL into teaching her gifted daughter.
And as for "social skills," hopefully you are aware of homeschooling groups AND of homeschoolers being allowed (by law) to use the public schools for things like art, music and PE.
School choice is needed and finding the best fit for the individual child is what should matter most.
