Replies to '10/07 The Latest Debates'

 
User Mood
Good

Message Emote
blank
October 7, 2005, 7:48 am PDT

10/07 The Latest Debates

Quote From: irishmom

I couldn't help but offer my opinions on these controversial questons.  As far as breastfeeding in public, I have to say that I was very nervous when my daughter was born because I didn't  think  I would   feel comofortable breastfeeding in public, but it's different once you have your baby.  I think that there are two extremes when it comes to breastfeeding in public.  Breastfeeding is natural and beautiful, not to mention essential to your child's health and well-being.  However, we do need to hold some standards of modesty in public.  I believe it's perfectly ok to breastfeed in public, as long as you are covered up.  I always kind of cringe when I see the woman who walks into the grocery store with a baby on her breast, baring it all for the world to see.  To me, breastfeeding is something sacred and should be done with some sort of modesty out in public. 

I DO NOT think that schools should be handing out condoms.  That is sending the WRONG message to children and I don't think it's the school's place.  Parents should be teaching their children about sex.  I think when we leave such topics up to a school to teach, there's bound to be chaos.  Our schools have enough trouble teaching our children in reading and writing.  Leave sex education up to the parents.  There are other places that children can get condoms if they so wish to do so.  (such as Planned Parenthood). 

I also do not belive that anyone else has a right to discipline your child if you are there.  If  your child is with another parent and you are not there, they need to be able to discipline your child. However, it would be a good idea to discuss acceptable discipline methods ahead of time.  I think if you are out in public and your child is acting up, it is nobody else's business to step in.  I know there have been many times I have WANTED to step in, but to do so would be rude and really wouldn't solve a thing except to offend the parent, which in turn would probably make things worse for the child!  If you see a parent abusing their child, however, then it MAY be appropriate to say somthing. 

I did not breastfeed either of my children however I feel it is okay when it is done discretely.  Yes it is natural however; mothers who choose to not be discrete seem to be making another statement, "look at me".    

 

Many times I went out with friends who breastfed in public and no one around them were even aware the baby was being fed.  Why must mothers openly expose to breastfeed?  As a mother who bottle-fed my children I had to be prepared with the appropriate tools to feed my sons.  What is wrong expecting breastfeeding mothers to wear the clothes or carry a small cover-up to once again be discrete?

  

 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 7, 2005, 8:34 am PDT

From another parent

Quote From: irishmom

I couldn't help but offer my opinions on these controversial questons.  As far as breastfeeding in public, I have to say that I was very nervous when my daughter was born because I didn't  think  I would   feel comofortable breastfeeding in public, but it's different once you have your baby.  I think that there are two extremes when it comes to breastfeeding in public.  Breastfeeding is natural and beautiful, not to mention essential to your child's health and well-being.  However, we do need to hold some standards of modesty in public.  I believe it's perfectly ok to breastfeed in public, as long as you are covered up.  I always kind of cringe when I see the woman who walks into the grocery store with a baby on her breast, baring it all for the world to see.  To me, breastfeeding is something sacred and should be done with some sort of modesty out in public. 

I DO NOT think that schools should be handing out condoms.  That is sending the WRONG message to children and I don't think it's the school's place.  Parents should be teaching their children about sex.  I think when we leave such topics up to a school to teach, there's bound to be chaos.  Our schools have enough trouble teaching our children in reading and writing.  Leave sex education up to the parents.  There are other places that children can get condoms if they so wish to do so.  (such as Planned Parenthood). 

I also do not belive that anyone else has a right to discipline your child if you are there.  If  your child is with another parent and you are not there, they need to be able to discipline your child. However, it would be a good idea to discuss acceptable discipline methods ahead of time.  I think if you are out in public and your child is acting up, it is nobody else's business to step in.  I know there have been many times I have WANTED to step in, but to do so would be rude and really wouldn't solve a thing except to offend the parent, which in turn would probably make things worse for the child!  If you see a parent abusing their child, however, then it MAY be appropriate to say somthing. 
I absolutley agree that it would be better if the parents discussed birth control / abstinence with their children.  However..... you have to enter the discussion with an open mind and not just say "don't have premarital sex or else!!!".  In that instance your children wouldn't tell you if they did decide to engage in sex with someone.  Personally I would rather know because I would buy the condoms myself.  That would be much better than getting pregnant or contracting an STD
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 7, 2005, 5:11 pm PDT

10/07 The Latest Debates

Quote From: irishmom

I couldn't help but offer my opinions on these controversial questons.  As far as breastfeeding in public, I have to say that I was very nervous when my daughter was born because I didn't  think  I would   feel comofortable breastfeeding in public, but it's different once you have your baby.  I think that there are two extremes when it comes to breastfeeding in public.  Breastfeeding is natural and beautiful, not to mention essential to your child's health and well-being.  However, we do need to hold some standards of modesty in public.  I believe it's perfectly ok to breastfeed in public, as long as you are covered up.  I always kind of cringe when I see the woman who walks into the grocery store with a baby on her breast, baring it all for the world to see.  To me, breastfeeding is something sacred and should be done with some sort of modesty out in public. 

I DO NOT think that schools should be handing out condoms.  That is sending the WRONG message to children and I don't think it's the school's place.  Parents should be teaching their children about sex.  I think when we leave such topics up to a school to teach, there's bound to be chaos.  Our schools have enough trouble teaching our children in reading and writing.  Leave sex education up to the parents.  There are other places that children can get condoms if they so wish to do so.  (such as Planned Parenthood). 

I also do not belive that anyone else has a right to discipline your child if you are there.  If  your child is with another parent and you are not there, they need to be able to discipline your child. However, it would be a good idea to discuss acceptable discipline methods ahead of time.  I think if you are out in public and your child is acting up, it is nobody else's business to step in.  I know there have been many times I have WANTED to step in, but to do so would be rude and really wouldn't solve a thing except to offend the parent, which in turn would probably make things worse for the child!  If you see a parent abusing their child, however, then it MAY be appropriate to say somthing. 
I agree with you on all these things. I think you said them well. I never really thought about the debate about breastfeeding in public before because I rarely ever see that. It makes sense to me that its completely fine to breastfeed in public, but yeah I think its common courtesy to cover yourself. I don't have kids yet but I feel right now that I would feel too awkward breastfeeding in public anyway, but maybe I will change my mind like you did. If I did ever do it in public, I would definitely use a blanket or something, because I'm just the kind of person who doesn't want my breast exposed. I don't understand why some mothers will get so flustered about it because they don't care if their breast is showing and don't see whats wrong w/ it.
 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
frustrated
October 8, 2005, 6:01 am PDT

Parents who don't discipline their children

Quote From: irishmom

I couldn't help but offer my opinions on these controversial questons.  As far as breastfeeding in public, I have to say that I was very nervous when my daughter was born because I didn't  think  I would   feel comofortable breastfeeding in public, but it's different once you have your baby.  I think that there are two extremes when it comes to breastfeeding in public.  Breastfeeding is natural and beautiful, not to mention essential to your child's health and well-being.  However, we do need to hold some standards of modesty in public.  I believe it's perfectly ok to breastfeed in public, as long as you are covered up.  I always kind of cringe when I see the woman who walks into the grocery store with a baby on her breast, baring it all for the world to see.  To me, breastfeeding is something sacred and should be done with some sort of modesty out in public. 

I DO NOT think that schools should be handing out condoms.  That is sending the WRONG message to children and I don't think it's the school's place.  Parents should be teaching their children about sex.  I think when we leave such topics up to a school to teach, there's bound to be chaos.  Our schools have enough trouble teaching our children in reading and writing.  Leave sex education up to the parents.  There are other places that children can get condoms if they so wish to do so.  (such as Planned Parenthood). 

I also do not belive that anyone else has a right to discipline your child if you are there.  If  your child is with another parent and you are not there, they need to be able to discipline your child. However, it would be a good idea to discuss acceptable discipline methods ahead of time.  I think if you are out in public and your child is acting up, it is nobody else's business to step in.  I know there have been many times I have WANTED to step in, but to do so would be rude and really wouldn't solve a thing except to offend the parent, which in turn would probably make things worse for the child!  If you see a parent abusing their child, however, then it MAY be appropriate to say somthing. 
I do not have children, so people think I should have no opinion on discipline.  However, every Sunday when I am at church and the same children continue to act up and their parents continue to do nothing, I get extremely frustrated.  I am not talking about a baby who is hungry or wet that is crying.  I am talking about children who are old enough to understand when to be quiet if they are taught.   I feel that it is extremely rude to the priest and to the other parishioners who are there to worship, not listen to unruly children.  The worst part is, we have a crying room where parents can take the children so the parents don't have to miss the mass.  I have spoken to the priest about it and he said in the past when anything has been mentioned to parents, they say if their child is not welcome, neither are they.  They are totally missing the point.  As Dr. Phil pointed out on the show, there are times when you can teach the children about public behavior and private behavior.   I don't get upset with the children, I get upset with the parents for not doing their job.  And if you have no control over your children, then get a babysitter.  I have been to many events where children should not have been present, but were.  Children do not have long attention spans and cannot be expected to sit quietly for hours on end.  When will these parents realize this?
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 10, 2005, 5:56 am PDT

Discipline

Quote From: irishmom

I couldn't help but offer my opinions on these controversial questons.  As far as breastfeeding in public, I have to say that I was very nervous when my daughter was born because I didn't  think  I would   feel comofortable breastfeeding in public, but it's different once you have your baby.  I think that there are two extremes when it comes to breastfeeding in public.  Breastfeeding is natural and beautiful, not to mention essential to your child's health and well-being.  However, we do need to hold some standards of modesty in public.  I believe it's perfectly ok to breastfeed in public, as long as you are covered up.  I always kind of cringe when I see the woman who walks into the grocery store with a baby on her breast, baring it all for the world to see.  To me, breastfeeding is something sacred and should be done with some sort of modesty out in public. 

I DO NOT think that schools should be handing out condoms.  That is sending the WRONG message to children and I don't think it's the school's place.  Parents should be teaching their children about sex.  I think when we leave such topics up to a school to teach, there's bound to be chaos.  Our schools have enough trouble teaching our children in reading and writing.  Leave sex education up to the parents.  There are other places that children can get condoms if they so wish to do so.  (such as Planned Parenthood). 

I also do not belive that anyone else has a right to discipline your child if you are there.  If  your child is with another parent and you are not there, they need to be able to discipline your child. However, it would be a good idea to discuss acceptable discipline methods ahead of time.  I think if you are out in public and your child is acting up, it is nobody else's business to step in.  I know there have been many times I have WANTED to step in, but to do so would be rude and really wouldn't solve a thing except to offend the parent, which in turn would probably make things worse for the child!  If you see a parent abusing their child, however, then it MAY be appropriate to say somthing. 
Forgive me, but you sound just like the Mom on the show.  She just set my teeth on edge, if she can't make her children behave in public then maybe she should stay at home with them until they are much older.  I am one of three children and we are very close in age, when we were little my Mom could have taken us anywhere, if we acted up in public we got a spanking.  It was just that simple.  All this lady did was make excuses for her children's awful behavior, like she was helpless to do anything about it.  Going out to dinner or a movie is a rare treat for my husband and I.  It always makes me furious when my night out is ruined by someone else's little monster.
 


Return to the Message Board


First Page | Previous Page | 1 | Next Page | Last Page