Replies to '10/07 The Latest Debates'

 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
confused
October 7, 2005, 10:30 am PDT

10/07 The Latest Debates

Quote From: tica1213

I am a mother of three who breastfed each child for two years.  I breastfed anywhere and anytime that my children were hungry.  And yet I NEVER exposed my breasts.  There were many times that friends and/or strangers would look at me and or talk to me and yet not even know I was indeed breastfeeding.  I live in Florida, where by law I can breastfeed in public.  I agree that  woman should be ale to breastfeed her baby ANYWHERE. I also know that there is no need to expose the breast while nursing.  There are specially designed clothes for discrete nursing and there are ways to cover up so that the worl does not see the breast.  I do not find it an unpleasant thing to see.  I actually feel sad for little babies whose mom's chose to not breastfeed so that they are less tied to the baby and more freedom to come and go.  How a mom cannot want to hold a child to her breast to feed him is beyond me and yet I understand that it a choice for everyone to make.  Mothers who do not breastfeed there children do not love their children anyless than those who do.  I am glad thati did and would never think of offering my baby formula when I have two breasts that work just fine.  I also think that mom's who say they tried to breastfeed and quit after only days or weeks, didn;t try enough.  Rarely does a mom not have enough milk for her baby. Ignorance, stress and lack of support or usually to blame. 

  

Marta P. 

Miami, Florida 

While reading your post, you had me agreeing and nodding my head...all the way up to the 3rd from the last line.  What on earth makes you such an expert as to say that?  When my daughter was born 15 years ago, mothers (especially new mothers) were made to feel like a failure if they didn't breastfeed.  So, wanting to be the best mother I could possibly be, I tried.  For 3 weeks I had a screaming, crying, totally upset baby attached to my chest.  I contacted the breastfeeding support group at the hospital where she was born, not once but numerous times and was told, every single time, NOT to supplement her with a bottle and to keep her on the breast only.  I remember sitting and rocking her at 3:00 a.m., tears running down my face, wondering how I could make this screaming object shut up.  Finally after 3 weeks I went back to MY doctor who immediately saw how horribly wrong everything was going and insisted that, for my physical and mental health as well as the health of my baby, I put her on formula.  It was like having a totally different child.  As soon as she got her tummy full she slept through the night and was a joy to have.  Preaching that "ignorance, stress and lack of support" is the cause of not enough milk is the most absurd statement I have ever heard.  My mother had 4 children over a period of 19 years.  She could have been a wet nurse with me and my sister; with both of the boys (who were born in the middle) she had NOTHING.  Needless to say when my son was born 3 1/2 years later, I vividly remembered the hell I went through and put him on formula immediately.  Both of my children are well adjusted, of well-above normal intelligence and are extremely loving, generous and kind.  I think if a woman enjoys the breastfeeding and is capable of providing for her child, it's a wonderful, precious thing.  But don't you dare make statements you are not capable of backing up, just to make yourself feel better.   

  

Michelle 

Bloomington, IN 

 

Message Emote
blank
October 7, 2005, 5:40 pm PDT

Thanks! That is the real debate

Quote From: tica1213

I am a mother of three who breastfed each child for two years.  I breastfed anywhere and anytime that my children were hungry.  And yet I NEVER exposed my breasts.  There were many times that friends and/or strangers would look at me and or talk to me and yet not even know I was indeed breastfeeding.  I live in Florida, where by law I can breastfeed in public.  I agree that  woman should be ale to breastfeed her baby ANYWHERE. I also know that there is no need to expose the breast while nursing.  There are specially designed clothes for discrete nursing and there are ways to cover up so that the worl does not see the breast.  I do not find it an unpleasant thing to see.  I actually feel sad for little babies whose mom's chose to not breastfeed so that they are less tied to the baby and more freedom to come and go.  How a mom cannot want to hold a child to her breast to feed him is beyond me and yet I understand that it a choice for everyone to make.  Mothers who do not breastfeed there children do not love their children anyless than those who do.  I am glad thati did and would never think of offering my baby formula when I have two breasts that work just fine.  I also think that mom's who say they tried to breastfeed and quit after only days or weeks, didn;t try enough.  Rarely does a mom not have enough milk for her baby. Ignorance, stress and lack of support or usually to blame. 

  

Marta P. 

Miami, Florida 

 You hit it right on the money!  It is not against breastfeeding in public, it is about doing it discretely. I know this might sound harsh, but those women who feel it is just "natural" to expose their breast for feeding their babies had exhibitionist tendencies before they had a baby.  I did not feel comfortable exposing my breasts in public before or after having a baby.  It is called modesty. 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 11, 2005, 10:28 am PDT

I agree.

Quote From: tica1213

I am a mother of three who breastfed each child for two years.  I breastfed anywhere and anytime that my children were hungry.  And yet I NEVER exposed my breasts.  There were many times that friends and/or strangers would look at me and or talk to me and yet not even know I was indeed breastfeeding.  I live in Florida, where by law I can breastfeed in public.  I agree that  woman should be ale to breastfeed her baby ANYWHERE. I also know that there is no need to expose the breast while nursing.  There are specially designed clothes for discrete nursing and there are ways to cover up so that the worl does not see the breast.  I do not find it an unpleasant thing to see.  I actually feel sad for little babies whose mom's chose to not breastfeed so that they are less tied to the baby and more freedom to come and go.  How a mom cannot want to hold a child to her breast to feed him is beyond me and yet I understand that it a choice for everyone to make.  Mothers who do not breastfeed there children do not love their children anyless than those who do.  I am glad thati did and would never think of offering my baby formula when I have two breasts that work just fine.  I also think that mom's who say they tried to breastfeed and quit after only days or weeks, didn;t try enough.  Rarely does a mom not have enough milk for her baby. Ignorance, stress and lack of support or usually to blame. 

  

Marta P. 

Miami, Florida 

Want to know what your state law says?

Take a look: http://www.lalecheleague.org/LawBills.html

Illinois says:

Public Act 093-0942, SB 3211, enacted August 16, 2004.

Section 1. Short title. This Act may be cited as the Right to Breastfeed Act.

Section 5. Purpose. The General Assembly finds that breast milk offers better nutrition, immunity, and digestion, and may raise a baby's IQ, and that breastfeeding offers other benefits such as improved mother-baby bonding, and its encouragement has been established as a major goal of this decade by the World Health Organization and the United Nations Children's Fund. The General Assembly finds and declares that the Surgeon General of the United States recommends that babies be fed breastmilk, unless medically contraindicated, in order to attain an optimal healthy start.

Section 10. Breastfeeding Location. A mother may breastfeed her baby in any location, public or private, where the mother is otherwise authorized to be, irrespective of whether the nipple of the mother's breast is uncovered during or incidental to the breastfeeding; however, a mother considering whether to breastfeed her baby in a place of worship shall comport her behavior with the norms appropriatein that place of worship.

Section 15. Private right of action. A woman who has been denied the right to breastfeed by the owner or manager of a public or private location, other than a private residence or place of worship, may bring an action to enjoin future denials of the right to breastfeed. If the woman prevails in her suit, she shall be awarded reasonable attorney's fees and reasonable expenses of litigation.

Section 99. Effective date. This Act takes effect upon becoming law.

720 ILCS 5/11-9, 1995 ILL. ALS 59; 1995 Ill. Laws 59; 1995 ILL. P.A. 59; 1995 ILL. SB 190;

Sec. 11-9. Public indecency. (a) Any person of the age of 17 years and upwards who performs any of the following acts in a public place commits a public indecency: ...

(2) A lewd exposure of the body done with intent to arouse or to satisfy the sexual desire of the person. Breast-feeding of infants is not an act of public indecency.
 
User Mood
Relaxed

Message Emote
blank
October 17, 2005, 12:02 pm PDT

Good Mom

Quote From: tica1213

I am a mother of three who breastfed each child for two years.  I breastfed anywhere and anytime that my children were hungry.  And yet I NEVER exposed my breasts.  There were many times that friends and/or strangers would look at me and or talk to me and yet not even know I was indeed breastfeeding.  I live in Florida, where by law I can breastfeed in public.  I agree that  woman should be ale to breastfeed her baby ANYWHERE. I also know that there is no need to expose the breast while nursing.  There are specially designed clothes for discrete nursing and there are ways to cover up so that the worl does not see the breast.  I do not find it an unpleasant thing to see.  I actually feel sad for little babies whose mom's chose to not breastfeed so that they are less tied to the baby and more freedom to come and go.  How a mom cannot want to hold a child to her breast to feed him is beyond me and yet I understand that it a choice for everyone to make.  Mothers who do not breastfeed there children do not love their children anyless than those who do.  I am glad thati did and would never think of offering my baby formula when I have two breasts that work just fine.  I also think that mom's who say they tried to breastfeed and quit after only days or weeks, didn;t try enough.  Rarely does a mom not have enough milk for her baby. Ignorance, stress and lack of support or usually to blame. 

  

Marta P. 

Miami, Florida 

There ought to be more hearts and minds like yours.
 


Return to the Message Board


First Page | Previous Page | 1 | Next Page | Last Page