Topic : 07/05 Liar, Liar

Number of Replies: 241
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, February 17, 2006, 03:18:31 pm
Author : DrPhilBoard1

(Original Air Date: 02/24/06) "I got stuck in traffic." "The check is in the mail." "No, you don’t look fat in those jeans." Everyone fibs once in a while, right? Dr. Phil talks to compulsive liars. Libby says her brother, Matt, destroyed their family with his conning and stealing. He ran up a $300 phone bill in his mother, Ellen’s, name, stole Libby’s social security number and racked up $6,000 worth of debt. Matt says he’s ready to come clean, but Libby and Ellen say he has told so many lies, they don’t know what to believe anymore. Then, Melinda feels her 14-year-old daughter, Tricia’s, lying is out of control. Tricia lied about being pregnant, but she has never had sex. She even told the police her father “beat the crap out” of her and had him arrested! Find out what prompts her to make up so many stories. Share your thoughts, join the discussion.

 

Find out what happened on the show.

More July 2006 Show Boards.


As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
anxious
February 27, 2006, 9:27 am PST

been there

Quote From: stoopid

My husband of over 25 years has been lying about money since before we were married.  He has lied about having paid the rent to the point of almost getting us evicted; he has lied about the car payment being made to the point of having the car repossessed; he has lied about making the payments on credit cards, furniture, appliances; the list goes on.  He once lied about having a job until I got the credit card statement and discovered that he had been taking cash advances every week to make it look as though he had a paycheck coming in.  He once pretended that our apartment had been broken into and my wallet stolen, when in fact he is the one who took money out of my purse. We have been separated for over two years, but a year ago he transferred money from one of his credit cards onto a card that we hold jointly.  He said he didn't know it was jointly held.  I asked him to get his balance off the card, he said he would.  But instead, he continued to transfer balance after balance from his cards onto that joint card until it is now at the limit.  I kick myself because I did not close the account while I had the chance, instead choosing to trust him for some reason.  He has been late with the payments on this account so many times that now my credit has been affected, after I worked so hard for so many years to clean up the credit mistakes of the past.  Yet I still can not bring myself to divorce him, because I love him.  You seem surprised that your boyfriend "says he still wants to marry" you.  Well of course he does.. why wouldn't he?  I hope you find the strength to free yourself from this situation. 
 Hi:  Been  there I  was writing  all of  the  checks to  pay  all of  our bills  with my  money  that I  was making.  He was making  3 times  what I w as making and was stealing my  money  by  ilegally  using my  debit  card.  When I  found out  I  went to the police!  of course they  took  a report but  did nothing!  He has nothing to  show for all of the  money he has made  I never  saw  new things going in the house.  He always has huge  wads  of  cash in his pocket .  When he  pays  a bill he  says he  paid  it with  a money order and later  I  always got  calls  from  our creditiors that they never  recieved payment!  So I confornt  him  and  it's the  same story  all over  again.  I  paid it I  swear  I did Where  is  the  reciept  for the money  order? Well it must be  in my  desk  at  work. Never found of course. What bothers me the most  is that He dosnt show up with new clothes  or anything that  I can  find. I  have followed his stepos  on the  computer I have  found nothing. Where  is  he spending  all of  this money?  I have given  up on him  ever being truthful or  responsible.  We have been  to  counselors. He  is  hostile towards  me. He is  verbally  abusive.  I  am  already depressed How are you dealing  wiht  your  husbands lies?  MY  credit is ruined  and  he could  care  less!  It's one of  those  Where do you go from here?
 
User Mood
Nervous

Message Emote
happy
February 27, 2006, 9:29 am PST

I definitely agree/understand!

Quote From: paloma1218

I want to yell "Liar, liar!!!!" to some family members but my mom tells me to stay quiet. She has a brother-in-law who lies and steals from them but she and her twin brother prefer to stay quiet and feel embarassment  by his actions towards them. Sad, huh? I don't understand how they have tolerate this low life. Sadly, his adult sons take after him and one of his daughter is a compulsive liar. I am glad I have distant myself from their crap, and I am glad my kids do not tolerate that crap either,  "Don't be fooled, bad company ruin good character."  1 Cor. 15:33.   

  

I use to feel all sorts of emotions when I use to frequent them but I don't frequent them any more. These people don't care if they get caught in a lie, they try to blast your character to feel better about themselves so to discredit you. They don't want to live in reality , they want to live in their own made up world and surround themselves with people like them or with a new batch of gullible people who do not know them well yet. These kind of people laugh at the lies they can get away with. These kind of people laugh about what they got away with stealing. These people feel no shame.  I would like to say that their pile of lies came crumbing down on them but they patch themselves up with more lies they use as a bonding agent. They don't get it.   

  

It is said what is in the dark will be made in the light. Only God can make them see. 

Paloma I totally agree with you! I read about that before. They stay in their guilt stage and to make them feel better they stay in their guilt stage by telling themselves lies and BELIEVING them! Not only do they believe them they have this way of convincing others to believe them! 

 

So now that I acknowlege this, I no longer dwell on the things my brother says to get people pissed at me. I just shrug my shoulders and say they can believe him or not, that's their decision but I am not wasting my time trying to get them to believe me. Life is too short to sit there and groan about who believes him over me! The family should all know by now that he is the one with the problem and if I say that he is lying, not to question me about it... It is a pathetic and childish thing to do. My brother's way of being sorry for raping me as a child, by lying to me, isn't going to cut it no longer... I put up with it in the past and pretended to be "over it" but now that I'm 18, I know better and am stepping up and will not tolerate it. 

 

For example, my sister in law has recently emailed me & her goal was to get me pissed at my brother for calling my mom and convincing her that I sent "mean emails" to my sister in law, when I didn't... My mom did question me but I said No, I didn't... and called him a liar and left it at that. I know what my brother is at and since I was just a little girl he's been wanting me to get in trouble and get people mad at me, and he knew his method worked. But instead of dwelling on it, I simply sent her back an email that said "I really could care less what he thinks and says about me. I know it's him, not me and I hate him too, so he can get people to believe what he wants... he has no reason to do this to me or to hate me, and I have very good reason with my method."  

 

So, I'm hoping with this attitude that I have now towards all this, changes something. I know it won't change my brother, but atleast I'm learning from all this and know what to do if I come in contact with another liar. 

 
User Mood
Apathetic

Message Emote
sad
February 27, 2006, 9:52 am PST

One line rings so true for me

Quote From: poppies30

I hear allot of women and I was one of them who try to help men like this.   YOU CAN NOT HELP HIM.    They have to want help even if he goes to counseling to make you happy it is not for him.   He is lieing about that too!    I lived with it for 13 years it took me that long to realize I could only help myself and I did.  I left.   Do not waste your life!  Get help for yourself with counseling.   Itf you stay you will be exhaustied and it will put you in a depression and you will need the medication.    If he really loved you he would do all he could to make it better. 

"If he really loved you he would do all he could to make it better." 

  

The biggest problem is he doesn't really seem to understand or care the impact.  He thinks marriage counseling will somehow give him empathy and teach him the "right thing" - but what I really think is that he believes I am completely overreacting and as he is so fond of doing, provng that I am wrong to care that I am being lied to. 

  

 
User Mood
Apathetic

Message Emote
hopeful
February 27, 2006, 9:53 am PST

Good luck parahort

Quote From: parahort

 I  really  do  appreciate your feedback.  It has helped me  tremendously!  I look  back at  our  relationship of just over 2 years and realize that I am  not sure that anything he  has ever told  me has had a grain of truth  in it! He has stolen money from me by  illegally  using my  debit card! I  caught him and he  swore that he  would never do it again!  Well he  did!  I  went  to the  police!  Of course they took a report but did nothing!  he  told me that he  would  tel the bank that I was attempting to  defraud  the bank! So I figured the  best thing  to  do  was cancel all debit  cards and  not  allow him  access to anything. I am  currently  planing  my escape. I was injured on the  job and permanently disabled.  Which  has not helped my  self esteem at  all!   For the  first time in 30 years I am not working which he  uses as a weapon.  That  since he is  the only one  working I  am his slave!  Wrong  He  truly dosnt  know me  at  all!  I am  suppose  to  be retraianed by the  Vocational Rehab folks and then I  will be able to hit  the  ground  running!  It's  just hanging on until then!  Keep  me  in your  prayers!
Good luck with your retraining and new job!  I will keep you on my prayer list.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
February 27, 2006, 9:55 am PST

costly

Quote From: mrsjah1003

I want to thank you so much for your answer to this matter.  I forgot to tell you that my mother and dad have been divorced for 12 years.  I have to now go to court because Jim's lawyers changing locks and everything, we are now fighting.  Again thank you so much.  I have been feeling that maybe I was wrong, but now I know that I am doing this not for me but for my dad.
 I lost my  Father 4 years a go!  Before he  was hospitilized I  was his  healthcare power of  attorney. sometime  while in  the hospital my  Mom  had it  changed, Dont  ask me  how.  My Father and I were like 2 peas in a pod and had been  since  I w as born. My  parents had  been  married  for 54 years at the  time  of my  Fathers death. I have an  Associates degree in Emergency medcal  Science.  Dad had a  AMI and  later had  a CVA.  He was doing well enough  that  he  had  been  moved  out of  the  unit and  to a  regular floor.  He contracted  Staff. And it settled in his lungs. So it  was back to ICU  and thats  when i found out  that I  wasnt  his HCPOA  anymore. My  mom nad my  sister actually  went to  the  Patient Right Actavist  people  and tried  to  make them take  him off of the Vent. The hospital Attorney told my  Mom  to her face that  waht  they  were suggesting  that they  do  was called murder.  I  was beside myself   when  they  did  pull the tube he passed  about 18  hours later.  I to this  day  cant forgive my family. I had made plans with  several of  my  friends to  steal  my Dad from  the hospital and have him  admitted  somewhere else.  I  feel that I  am responsible in some way  in his death.  I  had a  nervous breakdown lost my  business and everything,  because  of  this.  My  Dad  was  the one  person in the world that knew  me better than  anyone and  I had the kind  of  relationship  with  him that I  knew what  he  was thinking  and  he  knew  what I was  thinking. How  many times in a life time do you get that?  My life will never be right again.  I  can honestly tell you  that  it will get better with time. I am  able to  function now  on a daily  basis. I  would suggest  that you seek professional counseelingg ,  that's what it took  for me to be  able to  remember to  comb my hair after I woke up!
 
User Mood
Cheerful

Message Emote
confused
February 27, 2006, 10:06 am PST

Help your Daughter!

Why is Ellen paying for her son's apartment and phone, and not using that money to help her poor daughter pay off the debt this MAN left his sister with?  This poor girl continues to have a difficult time and her mother continues to perpetuate her son's behavior!  Help the victim mom!
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
February 27, 2006, 10:55 am PST

Little lies..

Bascially, my husband lies. All the time. Little lies or rather "omissions of truth" are they the same? I think so. 

  

Anyway, I have trust issues to begin with and threw myself into this relationship wih both feet. He has NEVER given up himself to me as far as trusting me goes. I never know where I stand, I never know where HE stands and when I ask outright, he just avoids the questions.  

  

The half truths and omissions have broken me down and now I don't trust him at all. Even when I have told him "you cannot lie to me, I can't take another person lying to me" he lies. WTF? 

  

I finally figured it out though. It's because he doesn't want to answer for what he has done wrong. He doesn't want to DEAL with me. In all honesty, he doesn't DEAL with a lot from me. I'm as far from a nagging bitch wife as you can get, but when someone lies to me, they have to deal with my wrath. That's the only thing I ask. He has never had to deal with anything more than everything he deserved for the situation.  

  

So rather than telling me the truth about money he's spent, people (women) he's been talking to or how many drinks or cigarettes he's had while he was supposed to be "working", he just doesn't tell me. The thing is, he thinks I'm an idiot and I'm far from it. I notice all the little hints, like the gum he chews to hide his cigarette breath or the need to take a nap immediately upon returning home before the last shot he had at the bar hits him and he starts to slur his words. I also manage the money so I always know how much is coming in and how much I need to pay bills. I rather quickly notice when there is say a $1000 descrepancy. And he wonders why I get pissed at him.  

  

People who lie are chicken shits. They just don't want to be accountable for their bad behavior. Period.  

 
User Mood
Apathetic

Message Emote
frustrated
February 27, 2006, 11:58 am PST

So true

Quote From: sxymomof5

Bascially, my husband lies. All the time. Little lies or rather "omissions of truth" are they the same? I think so. 

  

Anyway, I have trust issues to begin with and threw myself into this relationship wih both feet. He has NEVER given up himself to me as far as trusting me goes. I never know where I stand, I never know where HE stands and when I ask outright, he just avoids the questions.  

  

The half truths and omissions have broken me down and now I don't trust him at all. Even when I have told him "you cannot lie to me, I can't take another person lying to me" he lies. WTF? 

  

I finally figured it out though. It's because he doesn't want to answer for what he has done wrong. He doesn't want to DEAL with me. In all honesty, he doesn't DEAL with a lot from me. I'm as far from a nagging bitch wife as you can get, but when someone lies to me, they have to deal with my wrath. That's the only thing I ask. He has never had to deal with anything more than everything he deserved for the situation.  

  

So rather than telling me the truth about money he's spent, people (women) he's been talking to or how many drinks or cigarettes he's had while he was supposed to be "working", he just doesn't tell me. The thing is, he thinks I'm an idiot and I'm far from it. I notice all the little hints, like the gum he chews to hide his cigarette breath or the need to take a nap immediately upon returning home before the last shot he had at the bar hits him and he starts to slur his words. I also manage the money so I always know how much is coming in and how much I need to pay bills. I rather quickly notice when there is say a $1000 descrepancy. And he wonders why I get pissed at him.  

  

People who lie are chicken shits. They just don't want to be accountable for their bad behavior. Period.  

Well said......"The half truths and lies have broken me down. ....People who lie are chicken sh*ts.  They just don't want to be accountable for their bad behavior.  Period."  I couldn't have said it better myself. 

  

And I, like you, am NOT a b*tch when told the truth - but when someone lies to me, they have to deal with my wrath, too.   

  

I feel your pain. 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
February 27, 2006, 1:04 pm PST

I have something to say.

I'm a 23 year-old man, and I know what it's like to be lied to. When I was back in high school, I had a friend that I known in the neighborhood for 5-6 years. But then came a time for that. I've never, ever had a real relationship before, but this is kind of different. When the time came for my senior prom, I asked her out. Her response was, "No, I'm sorry, I have a boyfriend." Come to find out later, she didn't really have a boyfriend at all! Then before you know it, I found out that she had taken someone else out to the prom! Can you believe that? I was broken hearted when I found that out. But luckily, my mother knew a friend who would take me out. I then had a pretty good time. But I still managed to keep in touch with my friend now, and she now has about 3 kids. I have none, but at least I'm waiting for the right person to commit a relationship to(I'm waiting to get married before having kids). Hopefully, you can see it from my experience. No matter how many times people managed to hurt you, you must learn to forgive.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
February 27, 2006, 1:27 pm PST

It's one thing

Quote From: manofgoods

I'm a 23 year-old man, and I know what it's like to be lied to. When I was back in high school, I had a friend that I known in the neighborhood for 5-6 years. But then came a time for that. I've never, ever had a real relationship before, but this is kind of different. When the time came for my senior prom, I asked her out. Her response was, "No, I'm sorry, I have a boyfriend." Come to find out later, she didn't really have a boyfriend at all! Then before you know it, I found out that she had taken someone else out to the prom! Can you believe that? I was broken hearted when I found that out. But luckily, my mother knew a friend who would take me out. I then had a pretty good time. But I still managed to keep in touch with my friend now, and she now has about 3 kids. I have none, but at least I'm waiting for the right person to commit a relationship to(I'm waiting to get married before having kids). Hopefully, you can see it from my experience. No matter how many times people managed to hurt you, you must learn to forgive.

to forgive, quite another to trust. 

  

Do I forgive my husband for his weakness? Of course I do. It doesn't help me to trust him any more. The only thing that will help that is complete and total honesty at all times about all things.  

 

First | Prev | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19 | Next | Last