Message Boards

Topic : Ready for Marriage?

Number of Replies: 960
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, July 01, 2005, 05:09:04 pm
Author : dataimport
Contemplating taking the plunge? Talk with others who are ready to make things permanent.

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Cheerful

Message Emote
blank
January 5, 2006, 12:54 pm PST

Ready for Marriage?

Quote From: horseluver

    I have been dating my boyfriend for more than 2 years now.  I am 20 years old, and he is 18.  I love him very much.  He dropped out of high school his second semester of his senior year to become a manager of a company he's still working for.  The office that was here closed down, so he was going to have to move to continue working for this company, which was his dream.  But he didn't want to leave me, so I told him if he didn't leave, I would break up with him.  So he left.  He lives 3 hours away.  We didn't talk for the first 3 months he moved.  Then we started dating again.  I get to see him 2 or 3 weekends a month.  I have a hard time dealing with that because I want someone I can see whenever I want. And I'm dealing with depression so I feel like that makes it even harder for me.   He says that he's going to move back if he can when he opens his own office.  But he also says that there are not any cities near me that he can open an office in.  Did I make a mistake telling him to go?  I feel like I have...
    I have also asked him what his main priority in live is, and he said to be succesful... but mine is to find love and be happy.  And he said that, "well, if you're rich, then you're happy."... but I know that money doesn't buy you happiness. 
    He asked me to move to where he lives, but I can't even afford my car payments every month, I have a horse that I would have to have somewhere to keep, I'm still in college, and what would I do for a job?  Plus, I don't want to move away from my family.  I feel like, "well, you left me, so you should come back to me if you want to be with me."
    Someone please help me figure out what I should do!
YOU told him to leave or you would break up with him and now you are sad?  That is not fair.  I know it's hard to give in but come on, you have to be reasonable here.  Either you love him and want to be with him, if only for now a few times a months or you don't love him that much and need someone that you can see daily.  It's a tough call but love is real.
 
User Mood
Cheerful

Message Emote
blank
January 5, 2006, 12:58 pm PST

I did it.

Quote From: feelintrap

I have been married for 9 years and have been in a loveless marrriage for about 7 years.  I have two wonderful boys and am married to a man that lost someone before we met(his fiance passed away).  So throughout our whole marriage have felt like I was trying to always capture his attention and get him to like me.  We have tried counseling and now he lives in the house but a different room.  Finally after all of these years, I can't try anymore, I don't have the interest anymore, now all of a sudden he does.  I think we should separate and try that.  My question is, how does it affect the children if they never see love and only see a roomate relationship?

I actually loved my ex, he is amazing.  But we were friends, that was about it.  I knew there was more to a marriage than that.  We have to kids together, 7 and 11.  It was hard to decide but I left.  It was hard on them at first but with the love from both of us and support from both of us, they are great.  It has been 1 year and half and the kids have adapted well to all of this.  We share 50/50 custody, so the kids always know they have us both.  We never talk bad about one another and we always do right by the kids.  But this can be done, while you are not married.  

Trust me, seperate for a little while.  Either, you will learn that you want this marriage to work.  OR you will understand that living in a marriage for the kids, just doesn't make sense.  

Good luck and let me know how it goes. 

 
User Mood
Relaxed

Message Emote
hopeful
January 6, 2006, 9:05 am PST

How are you doing

Quote From: orion625

HAHA THATS PRETTY FUNNY THAT HAD TO HAVE BEEN THE FIRST TIME I HAVE SMILED IN SIX MONTHS THANKS . 

NOW I HAVE TO ADMIT THOUGH THAT I AM NOT A AVID READER OF THE BIBLE OR A WORSHIPER BY ANY MEANS BUT I HAVE BEEN GIVING IT SOME SERIOUS THOUGHT LATLEY AND I DUNNO I SEEM LOST AND CONFUSSED ABOUT PRETTY MUCH EVERYTHING IN LIFE LATLEY O WELL HOPEFULLY IT WILL ALL BE OVER SOON YOU KNOW WHAT I MEAN BUT YEAH I TALKED TO HER RECENTLY AND SHE SAID AHE MET SOMEONE THAT TREATED HER BETTER IN THREE DAYS THEN I DID IN THREE YEARS BUT I GUESS HE IS ON THE ROAD ALOT AND IT DIDNT WORK OUT I JUST KINDA GIGGLED IN SMALL TOWNS WHAT ARE THE CHANCES OF FINDING THAT SOMEONE RIGHT WELL I THOUGHT I DID TO TELL YOU THE TRUTH I STILL DO HA HA I ONLY PUT MYSELF THROUGH IT DONT I HA HA WELL HER MOM WISHED ME A MERRY CHRISTMAS AND I HOPE MY TIES WITH THEM HAVE ONLY BEEN SEVERED NOT BROKEN THEY ARE REALLY NICE PEOPLE BUT I GUESS WE WILL SEE WONT WE HA HA  

ANY WAYS HOPE TO HEAR FROM YOU SOON ALI  

ORION 

PS HAVE YOU READ THE PASSAGE OF THE FOOTSTEPS IN THE SAND I LIKE THAT ONE  

Hey there, Orion, Buddy, 

How are you doing?  

I have almost completed my sessions with my Psychologist, and I am feeling great. 

I have the odd flashback to J-bitch, but none as bad as some that I had whislt in the depths of my despair. I am finally out from under the denial, the anger, the depression. I am justy waiting for the day that we run ionto each other as we surely shall. I have to put on my happy face for that day.  

How are things with you, how was your Christmas and New Year? I hope you were with family that cared about you. I spent it with my Mom and Dad. I had three days off over that weekend, flew in to spend them "at home" with them. Boy, what a test that was. My Dad kept asking me "What time is your bus on Tuesday?" Nearly drove me insane. Still, it was a good time to just rest and get some of moms good old family recipes in my body. Now I need a bit of Dr Phil's Weight Loss Challenge medicine... exercise and diet... Oh Boy!! 

  

Hey, Hope 2006 treats you WAY better than 2005 ever did. 

Cheers 

Ali 

 
User Mood
Worried

Message Emote
blank
January 6, 2006, 9:16 pm PST

Ready for Marriage?

Quote From: jennife72

well i have been in the situation you are in years ago  

i was with a guy for 6yrs engaged for 4 of them and we lived together  

do you live with your b/f? 

i have been with my fiance for almost 3yrs and we just got engaged the day after christmas 

we do not live together because he knows that i have been there and done that  

and never got married 

so i think after 6 yrs you need to ask yourself do you want to just date the man or marry him 

and if he still does not know then you might have to give him an ulltimatum 

i mean i was patient with my b/f  

but it has only been 2 1/2 yrs  

but we are planning on getting married this fall and getting a house 

  

not sure if that helped  

but it lets you know it has all happened to us at one time or another 

  

let me know 

If you have to pressure someone to marry you, do you really want to get married to that person.  My brother's exwife pressured him and they ended up getting divorced after one year of marriage.  She thought she was ready and she wasn't.  They went through hell and I would hate for that to happen to you. If you know you're meant to be together, it will happen... why rush it?  True love will prevail. How exciting is it to say "I am engaged... after pressuring him".  It is more romantic if it was by his choice. 

 
User Mood
Worried

Message Emote
blank
January 6, 2006, 9:23 pm PST

Do I Marry or Move on?

I have been with my boyfriend for 5 years now.  I am 25 and he is 27.  We have gone through a lot together (lived overseas and in Canada, met in University) and we always prevail.  A big problem is that we are known as the "fighting couple".  We argue about everything and sometimes our arguments turn into insults.  I know Dr.Phil says not to bring up the past, but during our fights, I always end up bringing up the past because I am angry with him and hurt by the past.  I do not think he has cheated on me, but he always flirts with women and doesn't inform them of me... even if I am standing right there.  On one hand, he can be selfish, egocentric and doesn't help me with house work.  On the other hand, he can be sweet, caring and calls me just to see how I am.  When I am upset about something, he is the first one I call and he always helps me through my challenges.  He is my best friend.  Our sex life could be better, but since I brought this up, it is improving.  My problem is I don't know whether he is "the one" and I don't want to waste my time.  I am turning 26 in a month.  I love him and his family so much and I know that I would miss them and don't know if I want to leave him.  He tries to improve his willingness to help me with housework, but I often feel frustrated and alone.  Do I stay or do I go?  I can't imagine my life without him, but I am tired of arguing.  HELP!
 
User Mood
Stressed

Message Emote
blank
January 6, 2006, 10:13 pm PST

This is a no-brainer but I need the support

I recently was divorced from a man of 12 years because he was unfaithful and got the other woman pregnant.  At the time our 2 children were 2 and my son 3 months.  It was excruciating.  However, my friend had introduced someone to me after about 4 months.  I thought he was wonderful and had alot in common spiritually.  We dated and everything was great and I thought yes finally someone who respects me.  We bought a house together and got engaged christmas eve 2004.  Ever since then things went down hill.  He started quoting the bible on a daily basis making me feel that I was not doing the right thing.  Telling me I should limit my children to a toy so the house does not look messy. (even though every evening the kids and I do a round up and have a toy closet where everything goes)  He decided to take the kids toys and put it in an area they cannot access.  Always being critical about waste and how I should do my shopping.  And snacking, could not do it in front of him because he claims I had no self control.  I'm lucky if I eat 2 meals a day being a single mom with 2 toddlers.  I have continuously put up with this but the other day was the final decision maker for me but I need to know if I am being too harsh.  I am self employed and make enough money for myself and my kids to be comfortable.  I hired a cleaning helper to come in to my home twice a month which has been such a blessing.  He agreed months back to pay half just as everything else.  It was his turn to pay for them and he said that it was unneccessary to have them come in so often because the kids mess up the house after they leave.  But I explained to him it alleviates alot of the stress from me because they really do and excellent job for a very small price.  It came down to a battle because he does not want to pay for anything.  As it is I remodeled my kitchen doing alot of the work myself and hired a carpenter which he agreed but he then turns around and says it was my project.  Well the other day when we were discussing the cleaning team, he also said that he is getting screwed because he feels he should only pay for 25% because of me and my 2 children should pay 75%.  He then said my ex should pay for their share and I in turn said he does through child support.  He then said if he was paying half and I was getting child support then I am benefitting from it twice.  First of all child support does not cover alot as most single moms know.  I could go on and on but this is just a slice of it.  Let me know what you think PLEASE........I am so unhappy and would be better off with my kids and I..... 

 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
January 8, 2006, 3:53 pm PST

Ready for Marriage?

Quote From: 2ndthought

    thanks for replying. the problem is that i dont think u and i are in the same boat b/c ur boyf is telling where he sees a future. mine cant. we dont have any kids. he tells me he has committment issues and doesnt want to feel trapped --- what guy who truly loves their gf would view marriage as being trapped?????????????? I know its only been 7 months but the bottom line is that he has told me all this stuff aoubt how he thinks i ma the one and wants me ot his wife etc etc but told me he just doesnt know when -- i told him he may never be ready if he has fears of being trapped.

I am not sure if I am totally in your boat either.  My fiance says he wants to marry me and sees a future  and then his actions tell me otherwise.  He tells me what I want to hear even if it is not what he feels.  This keeps me confused all the time.  I guess if I were really honest with myself I would acknowlege that at the least, he is not ready for marriage right now.  At least your b/f is being honest with you.  He is not leaving any room for doubt.  I wish my fiance would say that to me.  I would explain to him that I don't want to "trap" anyone.  I want to be with him because we make each other happy so if he feels trapped we should part ways.   

I should do the same but I am the one who feels somewhat trapped.  I moved in with him in July.  My daughter was living with her dad but was having alot of trouble so she moved in with me a couple of months ago.  She had to change schools and she is doing much better here.  My fiance's daughter and her family live in my house because I am the dummy that suggested they could move there because they were financially struggling.  So if I leave him not only does his daughter have to move out of my house but I have to move my daughter back to the school district she didn't do so well in.  So I have decided to hang in there and have faith.  He is a very good man and we love each other very much.  We work on our relationship everyday.  I want to be married so badly but I suppose if I want him I have to be patient.  Which is not very easy for me.   

  

Look deep in your heart and be honest with yourself and you will find the answer but it might not be the answer you want to hear.   

 
User Mood
Depressed

Message Emote
blank
January 9, 2006, 1:11 pm PST

Ready for Marriage?

Quote From: divorcedma

I recently was divorced from a man of 12 years because he was unfaithful and got the other woman pregnant.  At the time our 2 children were 2 and my son 3 months.  It was excruciating.  However, my friend had introduced someone to me after about 4 months.  I thought he was wonderful and had alot in common spiritually.  We dated and everything was great and I thought yes finally someone who respects me.  We bought a house together and got engaged christmas eve 2004.  Ever since then things went down hill.  He started quoting the bible on a daily basis making me feel that I was not doing the right thing.  Telling me I should limit my children to a toy so the house does not look messy. (even though every evening the kids and I do a round up and have a toy closet where everything goes)  He decided to take the kids toys and put it in an area they cannot access.  Always being critical about waste and how I should do my shopping.  And snacking, could not do it in front of him because he claims I had no self control.  I'm lucky if I eat 2 meals a day being a single mom with 2 toddlers.  I have continuously put up with this but the other day was the final decision maker for me but I need to know if I am being too harsh.  I am self employed and make enough money for myself and my kids to be comfortable.  I hired a cleaning helper to come in to my home twice a month which has been such a blessing.  He agreed months back to pay half just as everything else.  It was his turn to pay for them and he said that it was unneccessary to have them come in so often because the kids mess up the house after they leave.  But I explained to him it alleviates alot of the stress from me because they really do and excellent job for a very small price.  It came down to a battle because he does not want to pay for anything.  As it is I remodeled my kitchen doing alot of the work myself and hired a carpenter which he agreed but he then turns around and says it was my project.  Well the other day when we were discussing the cleaning team, he also said that he is getting screwed because he feels he should only pay for 25% because of me and my 2 children should pay 75%.  He then said my ex should pay for their share and I in turn said he does through child support.  He then said if he was paying half and I was getting child support then I am benefitting from it twice.  First of all child support does not cover alot as most single moms know.  I could go on and on but this is just a slice of it.  Let me know what you think PLEASE........I am so unhappy and would be better off with my kids and I..... 

i am in a similar boat, my exhusband was a porn addict and beat my youngest of four black and blue. we are now divorced. i had met a man who accepted me and treated me better than anyone ever ever has. i also can support my own family and he did NOT contribute to the bills on any regular basis.  he also was harsh on the children and has decided after 1.5 years that he will never marry.  we just broke up.  i am taking it hard because i need love.  however, not at the childrens expense and have to think of their emotional well being first, as do you.  how will this treatment effect them long term?  their future relationships with men?  i am proud of who i am and all that i have been through and KNOW that there is someone else out there who will appreciate me AND my children.  WE CANNOT SETTLE.  it is all about the children.  some times we are better off alone than with someone wrong. difficult as that may seem.  i feel you pain, i feel mine too.  love can stink
 
User Mood
Stressed

Message Emote
blank
January 9, 2006, 10:22 pm PST

Thank you

Quote From: mshepard

i am in a similar boat, my exhusband was a porn addict and beat my youngest of four black and blue. we are now divorced. i had met a man who accepted me and treated me better than anyone ever ever has. i also can support my own family and he did NOT contribute to the bills on any regular basis.  he also was harsh on the children and has decided after 1.5 years that he will never marry.  we just broke up.  i am taking it hard because i need love.  however, not at the childrens expense and have to think of their emotional well being first, as do you.  how will this treatment effect them long term?  their future relationships with men?  i am proud of who i am and all that i have been through and KNOW that there is someone else out there who will appreciate me AND my children.  WE CANNOT SETTLE.  it is all about the children.  some times we are better off alone than with someone wrong. difficult as that may seem.  i feel you pain, i feel mine too.  love can stink
Thank you for your response to my situation.  It  has given me more courage to do what I have to do.  I never in my dreams thought I would ever be in a situation like this as you.  Children are a top priority and there is alot of women out there who don't think this way.  I commend you.  I OR ANYONE ELSE SHOULD NOT SETTLE FOR LESS THAN THEY DESERVE.  I've recently been given some advice:  Put a price tag on yourself, you are worth more than what they are willing to pay....
 
User Mood
Relaxed

Message Emote
hopeful
January 12, 2006, 3:35 am PST

What does your heart say to you?

Quote From: divorcedma

I recently was divorced from a man of 12 years because he was unfaithful and got the other woman pregnant.  At the time our 2 children were 2 and my son 3 months.  It was excruciating.  However, my friend had introduced someone to me after about 4 months.  I thought he was wonderful and had alot in common spiritually.  We dated and everything was great and I thought yes finally someone who respects me.  We bought a house together and got engaged christmas eve 2004.  Ever since then things went down hill.  He started quoting the bible on a daily basis making me feel that I was not doing the right thing.  Telling me I should limit my children to a toy so the house does not look messy. (even though every evening the kids and I do a round up and have a toy closet where everything goes)  He decided to take the kids toys and put it in an area they cannot access.  Always being critical about waste and how I should do my shopping.  And snacking, could not do it in front of him because he claims I had no self control.  I'm lucky if I eat 2 meals a day being a single mom with 2 toddlers.  I have continuously put up with this but the other day was the final decision maker for me but I need to know if I am being too harsh.  I am self employed and make enough money for myself and my kids to be comfortable.  I hired a cleaning helper to come in to my home twice a month which has been such a blessing.  He agreed months back to pay half just as everything else.  It was his turn to pay for them and he said that it was unneccessary to have them come in so often because the kids mess up the house after they leave.  But I explained to him it alleviates alot of the stress from me because they really do and excellent job for a very small price.  It came down to a battle because he does not want to pay for anything.  As it is I remodeled my kitchen doing alot of the work myself and hired a carpenter which he agreed but he then turns around and says it was my project.  Well the other day when we were discussing the cleaning team, he also said that he is getting screwed because he feels he should only pay for 25% because of me and my 2 children should pay 75%.  He then said my ex should pay for their share and I in turn said he does through child support.  He then said if he was paying half and I was getting child support then I am benefitting from it twice.  First of all child support does not cover alot as most single moms know.  I could go on and on but this is just a slice of it.  Let me know what you think PLEASE........I am so unhappy and would be better off with my kids and I..... 

I am a long way from ever feeling what you m,ust be, but I can just tell you, real people relationships are few and far between. Mainly because we so seldom meet real people. the fakes and charlatans we come across are only in it for hedonistic reasons. The men that both of you have described are not a true reflection of men in general. I hope you can move out from under his oppression and manipulation, and soon for the children's sake. My ex-wife is seeing a man that is emotionally abusive and I cannot convince her to leave him because she is financially dependant on him. Codependence is a bad thing when one is so completely wrapped up in guilt as my ex-wife is. 

Girl, get out, find yourself a GOOD man and make a great life for your kids as soon as you can. You never mentioned how old you are, but I would assume that you probably are in the region of about 30. You have  whole lot of living ahead of you, go for it, get better and get the best for your kids. 

  

 
First | Prev | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | Next | Last