Topic : Ready for Marriage?

Number of Replies: 1011
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, July 01, 2005, 05:09:04 pm
Author : dataimport
Contemplating taking the plunge? Talk with others who are ready to make things permanent.

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Relaxed

Message Emote
blank
May 24, 2006, 10:45 am PDT

I hope that this helps some

Quote From: mommy2cami

Dear Dr. Phil,  

   

I met a wonderful man about 9 months ago, and have been in a serious relationship with him for a little over 6 months now. I am 22 and he is 37.  He has been through 2 divorces, and the last one really nailed him bad, financially and emotionally.  His divorce was finalised about a month before we started dating.  He was engaged to his last wife for 2 years, married for 5, and separated for 1 1/2 years.  So all together he was WITH her for about 7 years.  I had just gotten out of a pretty rotton relationship of 3 years before we started dating, so we were both fresh meat, as the saying goes.  Our relationship progressed quite rapidly and we fell in love within a couple of months.  We recently got an apartment together and have been living together for almost 2 months.  I am so in love with this man and every day I find myself loving him even more.  But there are a few delemas..  I am on the verge of a custody battle with my ex-boyfriend with whom I have a 22-month-old daughter.  When I was with my ex-boyfriend he was constantly verbally abusive towards me, so when I decided that I wasn't going to take the abuse anymore and ended the relationship I moved out.  I ended up staying with my parents for a few months, but they did not want my daughter living there because of certain circumstances so she could not live with me.  My ex-boyfriend has had my daughter all this time and has only allowed me to see her a hand full of times.  Because of all of this mess I told this wonderful man that I don't know if I will ever be able to trust having another child with someone.  I would love to have another child someday, especially with such a loving and caring person, but I am scared to death about it.  I know that none of this is his fault and that most relationships come with old baggage and that everyone deserves a chance at things, but I am also scared of me, because I don't know if I will ever be able to love another child as much as my first because of the separation with her.  We haven't really seriously discussed having a child yet, thought the subject has come up.  He has no children and would like to have a child before the age of 40.  I would like to get your feedback on what to do and how to heal first.  The other delema is that I would like to get married to this man someday, preferably sooner than later(before having a child).  I understand that there is no rush, and for that I am content for right now.  One thing I do know is that marriage is the last thing on this wonderful man's mind because of all of the hurt and frustration that he has been through.  I think that he feels the same way about marriage as I do about having children.  He is scared to death.  We both love eachother very much, but how do we overcome such tremendous circumstances, if you would call them circumstances?  I would really appreciate your feedback on this message, as well as anyone else who would like to give some advice.  Thank you so much for reading =)  

   

   

Joanna  

I am going through the same thing with my first born I have a little girl that is almost 3 I have only seen her once since my mom took her from me but I also now have a one year old son and my Boyfriend has a little boy that he has not seen in 2 years so I can relate with you alittle bit the best advice that I can give you is to do what makes you and your man feel happy. If you feel that you are ready to have a baby with this man than go for it but if  you are not ready explane to him that you are not and that it will take time for you to be ready for another baby. I want another baby so badly but my man is scared to have another baby because of what his ex did to him and I am willing to wait for him to be ready. no matter how long it takes. If you truly love him you will wait and the same goes for him. I hope that this has helped you in any way. 

  

  

~Crystal 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
confused
May 24, 2006, 11:03 am PDT

ready for marriage but is he?

ihave been with the same man for 5 years  all and all we have agood relation ship hes anice guy and has agreat since of humar, we have been engaged for ayear  anddgetting him to set a date is  difficult we was going to do it this year things came up cant afford it so we are not doing it  isuggested  lets do it on vacation he seems to still be thinking about it im not sure if hes scaried of marriage cus his parents didnt have the perfect marriage and two of his brothers had cheated several times on there wifes so im not sure what he is thinking i dont want to pressure him but i also dont want to just be his live in girl friend . so any body with good advice  would help.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
May 24, 2006, 11:19 am PDT

ready but is he

Quote From: rose48602

I am 21 years old and I have been with the same guy for almost 2 years we have talked about getting married and even set a date last year but we could not go through with it. I know that I am ready to get married but how do I know if my Boyfriend is ready? We talk about it all the time but I just get this feeling that he is not ready and how do I tell for sure if he is. someone please help me.
hi iam going threw the same situation i have been dating the same guy for 5 years engadged for 1 year and getting him to set adate seems to be difficult more or less i think hes scared the best advice i cant give you is wait it out if the man is wonderful and he treats you good give him some time to think but also let him know that you love him but you are  not going to continue to be his live  in girlfriend that you want to be his wifeyou need to sit and talk withhim ask him how he fills about getting married if thats what he wants you dont want to pressure him into makeing a diccision that could make your sittuation worse or that you would brake up just sit down talk to him tell him how you fill and go from there.    bj
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
May 24, 2006, 11:50 am PDT

Ready for Marriage?

Quote From: divergrl75

I have dated this guy for 5.5 years. I am 30 and he is 33. He finally poped the question and we got engaged.  Sometimes I feel like we are really just roomates.  Here's some reasons why. One time I was out with some friends and they left and I got stranded downtown. It happens in large crowds.  So, I called up my boyfriend to pick me up and he didn't pick up the phone so I had no phone book with me and only twenty dollars.  It wasn't enough to get home via cab.  I hitchiked home and when I got home the phone was unplugged. I plugged the phone back in and there were my messages.  I got really upset because he had the energy to get out of bed and disconnect the line but not to answer the phone or pick me up.  I need to know if I'm making a mistake by calling it off and moving forward alone.  I'm going through some tough times at work and only working small hours and not making a lot of money.  we had a deal where I paid for the bills and groceries and he paid for the rent.  With the small amount of money I get, I focuss on paying the bills and THEN I go grocery shopping with what I have left. As I mentioned, I haven't been working as much so I haven't made a whole lot.  I paid off our bills but this time I couldn't afford to buy groceries.  When he found out I couldn't afford to buy groceries, he got mad and said that he would buy them AGAIN and that I am not to eat his food.  I thought we were suppose to be a team.  Several times I do remember buying with little that I have I would still buy him what he wanted.  Another thing that bothers me is that after 5.5 years he still can't say he loves me.  Guys just say that he has a hard time expressing himself.  I need to know the truth. I mean come on.  FIVE years and he still can't say it?  I quit eating his food and started to sleep on the couch. I figure that if he wants to treat me like a roomate, I will act like a roomate and completely cut him off from sex and sleep on the couch. I have been feeling so empty and it's making me wonder why I am with him.  I found out that when he was younger his mother didn't want anything to do with him and that it was only till he ws a teenager that she just got involved in his life.  His father is a lot like him.  Another thing I don't like is that he doesn't understand why I get upset about him looking at internet porn/girls.  At first it really didn't bother me then the more I thought about it, It did bother me.  He can look at other woman and can't say he loves me or even show me he loves me. That is why I feel so crappy.  I'm not getting or feeling any love from him.  It all comes down to this ring he bought me.........I think it was a "shut up" ring.  He doesn't like to talk about setting a date (It's been 3 months) he told his friend when he asked when were getting married 2 years from now.  I gave back the ring and now I'm thinking I made a mistake. I'm feeling really confused because I love him. I have already spoke to him about how I feel and he sais that he wouldn't be with me if he didn't care or love me.  How can I get him to say he loves me and to start being a fiance instead of a roomate.   Or, am I really wasting my time with this one.  He woke up this morning and just left to work without saying goodbye.  He's making out like nothing is wrong or like he doesn't care.  Any Ideas?
I can't even read the rest of this...just get out NOW. He doesn't care nor does he love you.  You are just there to take up space in his bed and to have someone to roll over on when he wants to.  When you are in a relationship and engaged you share everything.  Again, GET OUT!!!
 
User Mood
Distressed

Message Emote
blank
May 24, 2006, 12:53 pm PDT

Leave

Quote From: raineegal

I can't even read the rest of this...just get out NOW. He doesn't care nor does he love you.  You are just there to take up space in his bed and to have someone to roll over on when he wants to.  When you are in a relationship and engaged you share everything.  Again, GET OUT!!!

You need to leave. It's that simple. Believe me, you will find someone better.   

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
May 24, 2006, 2:43 pm PDT

In the same boat

Quote From: kindheart1

my name is bridget and i am 17 i'll be turning 18 in January and i'm getting married to the love of my life in march and his mother and father hates me with a passion. I dont understand it because I have been so nice to them and never said anything out of the way to them because I love my fiance and I dont want him in the middle of all this but he is and I dont like that.. They tell him not to marry me because I'm a trouble maker and a liar and that I'm no good..So we dont know what to do...We are not letting them come to our wedding or come to our house or anything because of the way that his parents treats us when we are together.  They are so harsh I'm a very sweet and loving girl and I always give everyong a chance because thats the kind of person that I am. I love my fiance with all my heart and soul but we just dont know what to do about his parents because they even abused him when he was little but he is nothing like his parents at all..He is so loving and caring it's hard to believe that he came from that mess you know.  So my parents are helping us by giving us their old trailer and helping us get started ...We love my parents cause they are willing to help us and approve of our marriage...So Please if you all have any advice or just anything please let me know....Thanks Bridget

I am in the same boat as you but it's MY parents that don't like my fiance..... we have been dating for 3 years now and got engaged this past Christmas... when I told my parents they were not happy at all.... they say I can do SO much better, but I love him and want to be with him. We have 2 kids and 1 on the way and I couldn't be happier. I mean sure we have our fights but what couple doesn't?? They were getting on my nerves so much about him that I just got up and moved away from where we were....I used to live in Manitoba, Canada and now I am living in Alberta. It makes me feel like my parents don't want me to be happy at all... his parents are very supportive of me and were VERY happy when we told them we were engaged!! I don't know what it is about parents today.... they way I see it is if your kid is happy BE HAPPY FOR THEM cause if that is the person they love and want to be with that is the one they are going to be with and seeing how 18 years of age you are considered an adult they really have no say in whom you want to spend you life with.... I let my parents make my every move till I was 19 and now they see I' living my life the way I want to live my life and they are finally realizing they have no say...I have a family now with this guy and I can't be any more happier then what I am!!!    

And as for you I think you guys should just go on living your life...if they love their son then one day they will come around and see who YOU really are and that you are not the bad person they think you are!!! Just hang in there.....   

   

   

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
happy
May 24, 2006, 3:58 pm PDT

Lots/Years of experience

Quote From: amanda_c_2

I am in the same boat as you but it's MY parents that don't like my fiance..... we have been dating for 3 years now and got engaged this past Christmas... when I told my parents they were not happy at all.... they say I can do SO much better, but I love him and want to be with him. We have 2 kids and 1 on the way and I couldn't be happier. I mean sure we have our fights but what couple doesn't?? They were getting on my nerves so much about him that I just got up and moved away from where we were....I used to live in Manitoba, Canada and now I am living in Alberta. It makes me feel like my parents don't want me to be happy at all... his parents are very supportive of me and were VERY happy when we told them we were engaged!! I don't know what it is about parents today.... they way I see it is if your kid is happy BE HAPPY FOR THEM cause if that is the person they love and want to be with that is the one they are going to be with and seeing how 18 years of age you are considered an adult they really have no say in whom you want to spend you life with.... I let my parents make my every move till I was 19 and now they see I' living my life the way I want to live my life and they are finally realizing they have no say...I have a family now with this guy and I can't be any more happier then what I am!!!    

And as for you I think you guys should just go on living your life...if they love their son then one day they will come around and see who YOU really are and that you are not the bad person they think you are!!! Just hang in there.....   

   

   

I am the parent of 2 girls 17 and 21, and would not take the chance of losing my relationship with my girls they mean the world to me.  Although I am supportive of them in the choices they make and advise them (sometimes strongly) when I think they are doing the wrong thing I still stay close with them.  If they just will not give up on the plan I let them go with it, but I can swear to you I have not been wrong yet about their choices of men and what the outcome will be.   

  

I also want you all to know that it is not easy being in a relationship or marriage with someone whose family does not like nor accept you, because the truth is your family are the only people who will always be there for you no matter what.  Take a step back and look at the reasons your family doesn't like your significant other and consider the reasons and be sure that you are right or are they? hmm 

  

Also if you have shared your troubles with your family regarding your significant other then that is part of the problem.  Don't air your dirty laundry to your family because they will always side with you and they will never forget the bad stuff. Find a friend or clergyman to talk about your relationship problems to. 

  

My 21 year old has recently gotten engaged to a wonderful young man who has a very sweet family and we all like each other.  They were friends first and he was a frequent visitor in our home before they even thought about marriage he is a good Christian man. 

  

For those of you who keep looking for love and hoping to find it NOW, wait it won't happen in your time, it happens in the Lord's time and when it does you will be 110% sure that it is right.  Remember this you have to be the kind of person that you expect in your mate! 

  

Some of you are so young and just looking for a way out of your current situation, be patient! 

  

  

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
May 24, 2006, 4:05 pm PDT

Ready for Marriage?

Quote From: sweetsilk

Ihave been with my live in boy friend for 5 years we have been ingaged for a year i made the arrangements to get married this september and something came up and we can not do it so i suggested that we do it w hen we go to the beach this year and just have aplan simple romantic on the beach wedding and its like he doesnt want to talk about it  and that he needs time to think about it im not sure if he has changed his mind or what he is thinking i have been with him so long and love him very much but does he fill the same im worried that he is just happy living together and that we may never get married.  

If he doesn't know he wants to get married to you after 5 years of living together and keeps putting it off it is time to kick him to the curb.  You are worth more than 5 years of free sex with no commitment.  Get yourself a real man honey!
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
May 24, 2006, 4:19 pm PDT

Ready for Marriage?

Quote From: bluebird30

My first time and I need help! I have been dating a man for 3 years. We are supposed to get maried at the end of July. But he has not told his daughter who is in college because he fears that it will upset her to the point of her not being able to finish. So basically he plans to give her a month notice. His mother and brother know about me . And he has been the dad in my kids life. He will not answer the phone or talk to me around her . She is spoiled but I do not think she will quit school because he has been divorced from her mother for about 10 years . Is this a valid excuse from him? I have told him that it makes me feel bad that after 3 years he will not tell his daughter . She is done with school , all she has to do is wait to get her diploma and go on a couple of class trips. Am I wasting my time thinking we really are going to get married?  He has told me that she has asked him if he was seeing someone and of course he says no . He even hides my picture when they come to visit. I feel like the other woman. But would he really tell the rest of his family of his plans to marry me if he was not planning to follow through. Help. I have no family to ask these things so I am depending on the readers here for help. Thanks for reading.

Does the rest of the family keep the secret from the daughter too.  Secrets are not good!  I can't imagine what the daughter is going to do when she finds out that he is getting married and has been with you for 3 years but never told her.  He's worried she will quit school? What a lame excuse.  Are you sure you want to get involved with a family that keeps secrets?  What will that teach your children?  Do you think that will change? 

  

I was married to a man with a family like that, we have been divorced for 19 years and his family still is like that they have not yet learned.  I am thankful I am not immeshed with that anymore and that my daughter didn't grow up around that. 

  

Life is too short to be unhappy or to keep secrets.  The truth is the longer he waits the worse it will be when his daughter finds out the truth and she will.  Maybe he doesn't intend to tell her because he doesn't intend to get married.  Something to consider. 

  

Good luck. 

 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
May 24, 2006, 11:12 pm PDT

Ready for Marriage?

Quote From: divergrl75

I have dated this guy for 5.5 years. I am 30 and he is 33. He finally poped the question and we got engaged.  Sometimes I feel like we are really just roomates.  Here's some reasons why. One time I was out with some friends and they left and I got stranded downtown. It happens in large crowds.  So, I called up my boyfriend to pick me up and he didn't pick up the phone so I had no phone book with me and only twenty dollars.  It wasn't enough to get home via cab.  I hitchiked home and when I got home the phone was unplugged. I plugged the phone back in and there were my messages.  I got really upset because he had the energy to get out of bed and disconnect the line but not to answer the phone or pick me up.  I need to know if I'm making a mistake by calling it off and moving forward alone.  I'm going through some tough times at work and only working small hours and not making a lot of money.  we had a deal where I paid for the bills and groceries and he paid for the rent.  With the small amount of money I get, I focuss on paying the bills and THEN I go grocery shopping with what I have left. As I mentioned, I haven't been working as much so I haven't made a whole lot.  I paid off our bills but this time I couldn't afford to buy groceries.  When he found out I couldn't afford to buy groceries, he got mad and said that he would buy them AGAIN and that I am not to eat his food.  I thought we were suppose to be a team.  Several times I do remember buying with little that I have I would still buy him what he wanted.  Another thing that bothers me is that after 5.5 years he still can't say he loves me.  Guys just say that he has a hard time expressing himself.  I need to know the truth. I mean come on.  FIVE years and he still can't say it?  I quit eating his food and started to sleep on the couch. I figure that if he wants to treat me like a roomate, I will act like a roomate and completely cut him off from sex and sleep on the couch. I have been feeling so empty and it's making me wonder why I am with him.  I found out that when he was younger his mother didn't want anything to do with him and that it was only till he ws a teenager that she just got involved in his life.  His father is a lot like him.  Another thing I don't like is that he doesn't understand why I get upset about him looking at internet porn/girls.  At first it really didn't bother me then the more I thought about it, It did bother me.  He can look at other woman and can't say he loves me or even show me he loves me. That is why I feel so crappy.  I'm not getting or feeling any love from him.  It all comes down to this ring he bought me.........I think it was a "shut up" ring.  He doesn't like to talk about setting a date (It's been 3 months) he told his friend when he asked when were getting married 2 years from now.  I gave back the ring and now I'm thinking I made a mistake. I'm feeling really confused because I love him. I have already spoke to him about how I feel and he sais that he wouldn't be with me if he didn't care or love me.  How can I get him to say he loves me and to start being a fiance instead of a roomate.   Or, am I really wasting my time with this one.  He woke up this morning and just left to work without saying goodbye.  He's making out like nothing is wrong or like he doesn't care.  Any Ideas?
Whoa!  Have I been in your shoes before!  This guy is immature and needs to grow up.  Not answering the phone when you call!  If there isn't more to this story, this guy is a selfish and self centered jerk.  You can't make him say he loves you or make him marry you.  You can tell him that if things don't seriously change, he will lose you.  Start by stating it in a way that is not accusatory.  Tell him how his actions are interpreted by you and how they make you feel.  Tell him his actions do not follow suit with loving or caring about someone.  I am with a guy who used to act like this and it took huge fights to get his true feelings out.  After four years of being together, we had an unexpected pregnancy that woke him up, and forced him to step up and grow up.  I am in no way suggesting you get pregnant, I am just saying that some men need life changing events to get their priorities in order.  My advice: Don't wait around for him to grow up.  If he's not willing to give you the commitment you need, there's a problem.  The only way I would stay with him is if he agreed marital/ relationship counseling.  Good luck!  Listen to your gut and you will know if he's worth spending more time on.
 
First | Prev | 33 | 34 | 35 | 36 | 37 | 38 | 39 | 40 | 41 | 42 | Next | Last