Message Boards

Topic : 03/01 Sudden Fame

Number of Replies: 128
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, February 23, 2007, 02:16:13 pm
Author : DrPhilBoard1
Do you wish the whole world knew your name? Do you wonder how it would feel to stroll down the red carpet or have the paparazzi waiting for you as you walked out of a restaurant? Jennifer recently auditioned for American Idol, but didn’t make the final cut to go to Hollywood. She thinks about her failed performance every day, and says Simon Cowell crushed her dreams. Will she be able to regain her confidence when she performs on the show? Then, Elizabeth says she’s determined to make her 9-year-old daughter famous. Her sister, Priscilla, says her niece is too heavy and doesn’t have the talent to make it. Is Elizabeth setting her daughter up for failure, or should Priscilla mind her own business? Plus, Taylor Hicks went from virtual obscurity to instant fame …all with the help of 64 million American Idol viewers. Don’t miss Taylor’s riveting performance, talk about the show here!

Find out what happened on the show.

More March 2007 Show Boards.

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
March 1, 2007, 6:57 pm PST

03/01 Sudden Fame

Quote From: jamandbread

This show was so trivial compared to the blind/deaf triplets.  They need to do the mom's care taking job for 3 days  to put them back  into the real world.
It really was quite a contrast.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
March 1, 2007, 7:14 pm PST

whatever

Quote From: a19f21

First of all, I'm the Jennifer who is shown on today's show. I had decided not to post and get involved in this discussion, but I just feel led to at least make this post.   I just feel like a few things need to be explained. To start it off, I want to make it clear that I do not regret going on the Dr. Phil show. The show was extremely nice and respectful to me, and they truly treated me like a queen while I was there. I will be forever grateful for the opportunity they allowed me.   I signed up for two Dr. Phil shows: "Want Second Chance at Dream?" and "Embarassing Moment Caught on Tape?" I didn't even know the show I was on was geared towards people who wanted to become famous until I was actually on stage filming with Dr. Phil. I don't want that statement to come out sounding like I am complaining, though, because I definitely know the show didn't try to do anything harmful by "casting" me for a different show than I signed for. Like I said, I am very grateful for the opportunity.   I do not want to become "famous." I want to be a singer...and if God allows me to become "famous" through singing, then so be it. There is a really big difference. I didn't appear on the show to say "Here I am...Make Me Famous!" I appeared on the show for two reasons only: to tell about my experience on American Idol and to sing.   So about American Idol....it was NOT a bad experience for me. It was actually pretty good up until the end of the 4th round, where I was cut...and even then it wasn't DEVESTATING, just, of course, not how I would have liked it to have gone.   If you have never made it to at least the second round of American Idol, you don't completely understand how the process works. The judges are actually round 4. You have to pass many interviews and many auditions before you get to the judges. The producers have lots of time to decide exactly what they are going to do with you, and a lot of the stuff is extrememly scripted...but hey, that's TV. In the interviews, if they hear you say one thing that they think they can take and run with, they will. But that's TV, too. In my interview, I was asked: Who is your favorite singer? I answered Paula Abdul. Who is your American Idol? Paula Abdul. Then on down the line I was asked to tell about something I have done that sets me apart from others...something no one else has done. I mentioned that I had actually been on a TV show with Paula Abdul prior to auditioning for American Idol. Without meaning to, I was labeled the "Paula Abdul Girl." There were many, many other stories I told them, but, for obvious reasons, that one stuck out to them.   I was NEVER, EVER upset because I didn't MAKE American Idol. I was upset at what happened at my round 4 audition. When I walked in, Simon point blanked asked me, "So I hear you are obsessed with Paula Abdul?" I remember looking at him with this really confused expression, because I honestly couldn't think of anything I had said or done to imply I was obsessed with anyone. I explained to Simon, in a nice, calm manner, that I was actually just a fan and would never be the type of person to be obsessed with anyone. That was cleared and we moved on. Like many of you have said, I "should have known how he was." To make it clear...I do know how he is. I've seen the show for all 5.5 seasons now, and I have also seen it live in Hollywood. I just wanted my chance to state for the record that I am not obsessed with anyone, so that is one reason I contacted Dr. Phil. I don't HATE Simon or hold anything against him. True, I do wish he wouldn't have tried to make it seem like I was obsessed with someone, but like I keep saying, that's TV, too. The other part I was upset over is that I didn't get to sing the song I had prepared. I prepared "Part Time Lover," by Stevie Wonder, along with a few others. When I walked into the round 4 audition room...on camera, I was asked to sing "Can't Get You Out of My Head," by Kylie Minogue. At the time, I didn't know the song, so I was basically in a "sink or swim" situation. I decided to tempt the song, but because I only knew two lines and didn't know the actual tune, Simon's critique was, well, harsh. If you watched the Birmingham episode, I was shown in a red shirt saying, "Thank you very much. Bye." I did not cuss, cry, or scream. I actually walked out of the room, hugged Ryan, and looked into the camera and said, "I'm from a really small town...I'm just glad I had this opportunity." I was NEVER mad or angry at Simon or American Idol, and I still continue to watch the show every night it is on. My favorite judges? Paula AND Simon. I also contacted Dr. Phil because I wanted my fair chance to sing a song I do knew and was prepared for.   The last part I was upset over is that Paula was not at auditions that day in Birmingham...not upset at Paula herself, just the disappointment of her not being there. She had a family event back home in California. I had really gotten my hopes up to sing for my favorite singer, so that just added to the disappointment.   So I contacted the Dr. Phil show to tell my American Idol story and to get to sing in Hollywood. Never once did I mean to imply to anyone that I desired fame and would stop at nothing to get it.   But, to end this, I need to mention again that I am very grateful to the Dr. Phil show for allowing me the wonderful opportunity to be a guest on his show. If I had to do it all over again, I would....except this time I would be sure to mention that I don't "desire fame," but simply would love to be a singer...whether that be on TV or at a small event in my hometown.   But anyway, to completely humble myself, thank you all for reading. I wish you all success in whatever you do. Be an American Idol at whatever that is - whether it be an American Idol teacher, and American Idol doctor, and American Idol Mom and Dad...the list goes on. As for me, I am very content in being an American Idol teacher right now. I have 21 little students and a whole school full of people who are very excited to hear me sing on today's show...and THAT'S what matters most in life. 100 years from now it will not matter whether I made American Idol or not, whether I sang a song I prepared or not, or whether I was on a talk show or not....it will matter that I was important in the life of a child.   God bless you all.
Your entire message was nice and seemed sincere but you did make a HUGE deal out of it, way over the top. You are the one confusing us all. Get on with your life.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
March 1, 2007, 7:15 pm PST

Thanks! =)

Quote From: fourdogspal

Jennifer, you were brave to share your story and your disappointment, especially because you were in the midst of loss and grief. Thanks for expanding the story and responding so kindly to the person who commented. That says a lot about you, as did your willingness to move beyond your fear and share your lovely voice with such a massive audience. Whatever happens to you in the future, I'm sure you will be a star to the people who matter most to you. That's what truly makes life rewarding, isn't it--much more so than having momentary recognition from a celebrity who would never be fully invested in your life. I respect what Paula Abdul has accomplished with her life, but I certainly don't envy her fame. Sometimes I sense loneliness and pain behind her smiling face. I suspect that celebrity status can be extremely isolating. People clammer to be near you for your persona, not for who you really are. How empty that would be! I can tell that you have people in your life who care deeply for who you really are. You are indeed fortunate, young lady.

Thank you so much! Your post really means a lot to me. I wish you all the luck and success in the world! My students were shown on the show today, and I just know that will be a thrill to them. They were so excited when school let out today, and just knowing that I helped put that excitement into their lives is really rewarding! They were some of my biggest supporters during and after American Idol.

 

The Dr. Phil show chose "Amazing Grace" for me, because it's a free song that you don't have to have copyrights for. I wouldn't have picked it for myself, but I was willing to go along with their choice. It's unfortunate that I was so nervous...I could hear my voice shaking like a leaf. No matter what, though, I truly enjoyed it and am still so thankful for that opportunity!

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
March 1, 2007, 7:17 pm PST

03/01 Sudden Fame

Quote From: olivertup

Are you the girl who was on today? I feel like such a big jerk because I wrote this before I heard the whole story, (I still haven't watched it but I'm about to). I"M SO SORRY!!!

 

That was just dumb of me to post something before I even watched the show. I did that yesterday too and it's just dumb of me. I won't be doing that again and I really hope that you'll excuse my oversight and sarcasm, (I feel so bad!!!) SORRY!!!!!!

 

Well, it was against my better judgement to say something critical anyway. Next time I'll think before I speak. I'm sure you're a great singer and that there's much more to your story and why you were upset. I'm gonna go watch it now.

 

Take care!  

Hi! It's okay....don't worry about it! Contrary to what was shown today, I am actually a very tough-skinned person. I've gone on many a message boards and posted my thoughts on people I have seen on TV, too. It's only human nature as TV viewers that we do that. I know I'm not above anyone else in being discussed on message boards. Thank you for your sweet post! Have a great day! Jennifer
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
March 1, 2007, 7:40 pm PST

03/01 Sudden Fame

Quote From: penny_lady

Hi again fellow atheist!
Hello again!!!
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
March 1, 2007, 8:36 pm PST

Do you work with a vocal trainer?

Quote From: a19f21

Thank you so much! Your post really means a lot to me. I wish you all the luck and success in the world! My students were shown on the show today, and I just know that will be a thrill to them. They were so excited when school let out today, and just knowing that I helped put that excitement into their lives is really rewarding! They were some of my biggest supporters during and after American Idol.

 

The Dr. Phil show chose "Amazing Grace" for me, because it's a free song that you don't have to have copyrights for. I wouldn't have picked it for myself, but I was willing to go along with their choice. It's unfortunate that I was so nervous...I could hear my voice shaking like a leaf. No matter what, though, I truly enjoyed it and am still so thankful for that opportunity!

If you want to make it singing, you HAVE to get some training. I know you were nervous today, but you were off key a few times. I only say this because I majored in theater, and I have been in several musicals, and I KNOW how hard you have to work to strenghten your voice. It's not just raw talent, you have to have pitch, know when to breathe, and work on the phrasing.

 

I could tell that you enjoy singing, but it was painful to hear at times, because it was really pitchy and off key.

 

I am not saying this to be mean, I am telling you the truth in what i heard.

 

Your vocal chords are like any other muscle in your body. You can't expect to run a 26 mile marathon if you have never gotten on a treadmill. It takes dedication to do so.

 

Best of luck...

wenchy

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
March 1, 2007, 8:58 pm PST

Talent

Quote From: cats88

 

 

What a frustrating piece!

 

What is wrong with supporting your child's desire to become ANYTHING they Desire?

 

I am sure everyone has seen the video coverages of Beyonce, The Osmonds, Jacksons,

 Tiger Woods, Wayne Gretsky as children being "coached" or "pushed" at their rehearsals and practices?!   We know today some of the boys from the Jacksons & Osmonds felt it to be very difficult and overwhelming at times. But overall the people listed above  are very successful and claim to be happy about where they are at today and grateful to their parents for their support and help along the way.

 

The dedication of the parents did help them accomplish their hearts' desire.  So clearly what is the big deal with this Mom. Sure her little girl doesn't as yet have the greatest voice but with practice and lessons who knows.....

 

I think the Mom's sister needs to calm down a bit and not make such a big deal about everything.  All the fuss and commotion can cause some confusion and perhaps make the little girl want to sing for all the wrong reasons, like to prove a point - "I'll show You" kind of attitude and could unfortunately make her loose sight of what she truly wants.

 

Love most of what you say Dr. Phil but I think you missed this aspect of the situation.

Good luck to the Mom & little girl

 

                                     -- Never give up your love of music--

 You may never become a "Superstar" but the places your music can take you are                         boundless with the potential to to amaze and reward you even more than you think.

Without a doubt NEVER let go of your dreams.

You missed one really important aspect , ALL THESE PEOPLE HAVE TALENT
 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
March 1, 2007, 9:29 pm PST

jennifer

Quote From: a19f21

First of all, I'm the Jennifer who is shown on today's show. I had decided not to post and get involved in this discussion, but I just feel led to at least make this post.   I just feel like a few things need to be explained. To start it off, I want to make it clear that I do not regret going on the Dr. Phil show. The show was extremely nice and respectful to me, and they truly treated me like a queen while I was there. I will be forever grateful for the opportunity they allowed me.   I signed up for two Dr. Phil shows: "Want Second Chance at Dream?" and "Embarassing Moment Caught on Tape?" I didn't even know the show I was on was geared towards people who wanted to become famous until I was actually on stage filming with Dr. Phil. I don't want that statement to come out sounding like I am complaining, though, because I definitely know the show didn't try to do anything harmful by "casting" me for a different show than I signed for. Like I said, I am very grateful for the opportunity.   I do not want to become "famous." I want to be a singer...and if God allows me to become "famous" through singing, then so be it. There is a really big difference. I didn't appear on the show to say "Here I am...Make Me Famous!" I appeared on the show for two reasons only: to tell about my experience on American Idol and to sing.   So about American Idol....it was NOT a bad experience for me. It was actually pretty good up until the end of the 4th round, where I was cut...and even then it wasn't DEVESTATING, just, of course, not how I would have liked it to have gone.   If you have never made it to at least the second round of American Idol, you don't completely understand how the process works. The judges are actually round 4. You have to pass many interviews and many auditions before you get to the judges. The producers have lots of time to decide exactly what they are going to do with you, and a lot of the stuff is extrememly scripted...but hey, that's TV. In the interviews, if they hear you say one thing that they think they can take and run with, they will. But that's TV, too. In my interview, I was asked: Who is your favorite singer? I answered Paula Abdul. Who is your American Idol? Paula Abdul. Then on down the line I was asked to tell about something I have done that sets me apart from others...something no one else has done. I mentioned that I had actually been on a TV show with Paula Abdul prior to auditioning for American Idol. Without meaning to, I was labeled the "Paula Abdul Girl." There were many, many other stories I told them, but, for obvious reasons, that one stuck out to them.   I was NEVER, EVER upset because I didn't MAKE American Idol. I was upset at what happened at my round 4 audition. When I walked in, Simon point blanked asked me, "So I hear you are obsessed with Paula Abdul?" I remember looking at him with this really confused expression, because I honestly couldn't think of anything I had said or done to imply I was obsessed with anyone. I explained to Simon, in a nice, calm manner, that I was actually just a fan and would never be the type of person to be obsessed with anyone. That was cleared and we moved on. Like many of you have said, I "should have known how he was." To make it clear...I do know how he is. I've seen the show for all 5.5 seasons now, and I have also seen it live in Hollywood. I just wanted my chance to state for the record that I am not obsessed with anyone, so that is one reason I contacted Dr. Phil. I don't HATE Simon or hold anything against him. True, I do wish he wouldn't have tried to make it seem like I was obsessed with someone, but like I keep saying, that's TV, too. The other part I was upset over is that I didn't get to sing the song I had prepared. I prepared "Part Time Lover," by Stevie Wonder, along with a few others. When I walked into the round 4 audition room...on camera, I was asked to sing "Can't Get You Out of My Head," by Kylie Minogue. At the time, I didn't know the song, so I was basically in a "sink or swim" situation. I decided to tempt the song, but because I only knew two lines and didn't know the actual tune, Simon's critique was, well, harsh. If you watched the Birmingham episode, I was shown in a red shirt saying, "Thank you very much. Bye." I did not cuss, cry, or scream. I actually walked out of the room, hugged Ryan, and looked into the camera and said, "I'm from a really small town...I'm just glad I had this opportunity." I was NEVER mad or angry at Simon or American Idol, and I still continue to watch the show every night it is on. My favorite judges? Paula AND Simon. I also contacted Dr. Phil because I wanted my fair chance to sing a song I do knew and was prepared for.   The last part I was upset over is that Paula was not at auditions that day in Birmingham...not upset at Paula herself, just the disappointment of her not being there. She had a family event back home in California. I had really gotten my hopes up to sing for my favorite singer, so that just added to the disappointment.   So I contacted the Dr. Phil show to tell my American Idol story and to get to sing in Hollywood. Never once did I mean to imply to anyone that I desired fame and would stop at nothing to get it.   But, to end this, I need to mention again that I am very grateful to the Dr. Phil show for allowing me the wonderful opportunity to be a guest on his show. If I had to do it all over again, I would....except this time I would be sure to mention that I don't "desire fame," but simply would love to be a singer...whether that be on TV or at a small event in my hometown.   But anyway, to completely humble myself, thank you all for reading. I wish you all success in whatever you do. Be an American Idol at whatever that is - whether it be an American Idol teacher, and American Idol doctor, and American Idol Mom and Dad...the list goes on. As for me, I am very content in being an American Idol teacher right now. I have 21 little students and a whole school full of people who are very excited to hear me sing on today's show...and THAT'S what matters most in life. 100 years from now it will not matter whether I made American Idol or not, whether I sang a song I prepared or not, or whether I was on a talk show or not....it will matter that I was important in the life of a child.   God bless you all.
jennifer,  i saw you today on dr. phil.   i also think you went way overboard with this.  i listened to you  sing. and  im sorry,  but your not that good.  i do  give you props for  going for your dream, that takes alot of courage.  we all have to realize at times, there's fantasy, and reality. as far as the paula abdul stuff,  im sure it was blown up to be something it wasnt., you hardly  seem like a stalker.. we all have dreams, but if ya dont  have it, ya move on.  you just seemed to come across as this whole thing has ruined you.   your better than that girl!!   i hope you find happiness in whatever you decide to to do.  
 
User Mood
Excited

Message Emote
giddy
March 1, 2007, 10:39 pm PST

i love you, taylor

I love taylor hicks.

the guy is totally awesome.

he is my all time favorite singer;

knocking out  both Elvis and CCR

from my #1 spot.

dr PHil and Robin please please please

have taylor back on your show again and again and again

and again and again.  Just make him a regular fixture.

 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
sad
March 1, 2007, 10:42 pm PST

Mother who wants to live her daughter's life

I watched your show and it did not surprise me to see how Elizabeth was speaking about her daughter. When my daughter was growing up she wanted to be in pageants and not because I insisted. She did win and lose some too, but it was her chose not MINE and that is what Elizabeth needs to do is back off from in my mind forcing her to be something she is not ready for. I applaud Priscilla is speaking her mind to give her sister a wake up call. Watching Elizabeth speak to you how much her daughter wanted this, talking about how famous she is going to be, but one thing I did not hear from Elizabeth is how well her daughter is doing in school. Education is TOPS before FAME!  I hope Elizabeth left your show thinking differently.
 
First | Prev | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | Next | Last