Message Boards

Topic : 06/11 Scary Skinny

Number of Replies: 391
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, November 02, 2007, 11:53:05 am
Author : DrPhilBoard1
(Original Air Date: 11/16/07) We live in a culture that glamorizes svelte celebrities from Angelina Jolie to Paris Hilton. But some women put their lives in jeopardy for the sake of being skinny.  Twenty-three-year-old Jessica weighs 95 pounds and has battled anorexia for 10 years. She says she’s obsessed with exercising and counting calories, and only sees a fat woman when she looks in the mirror. Jessica’s younger sister, Theresa, fears for Jessica’s life but doesn’t know how to approach her. What’s at the root of Jessica’s disorder? Find out why the siblings say the answer lies in their childhood. Then, Jessica isn’t the only one in her family fighting anorexia. Her 12-year-old cousin, Nicole, was recently hospitalized because she lost 60 pounds in the last three months -- all in an effort to look like Nicole Richie. Don’t miss Dr. Phil’s strong message for the young women. Plus, Alita became bulimic at the age of 17 when she weighed 220 pounds. Now, at 24, she’s 95 pounds lighter but still wants to lose weight. Alita says she binges every day -- eating up to six plates of food at a time -- and then purges. She gives Dr. Phil camera crews a disturbing look at a day in her life. And, Alita’s father, Frank, worries that she’ll die if she doesn’t get help soon. Is Frank enabling her bulimia? Share your thoughts here.

Find out what happened on the show.

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
January 10, 2008, 6:01 pm PST

11/16 Scary Skinny

I just wanted to say thanks to dr. phil for having this episode.  I was in tears the whole show.  I could relate to everything she was going through.  The show made me feel not so alone. 
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
January 16, 2008, 10:42 am PST

For Jessica

I happen to know Jessica, I went to school with her last year and she was my best friend's roommate for a while. I just wanted to offer some words of encouragment to her, and to let her know that if she is capable of all of the awesome things that she has already accomplished in her education and her blossoming carreer, she is definitely capable of kicking this. She has the work ethic, and the drive, and she just needs to focus it on the number one important thing right now. Herself. Good Luck Jessica, Jillian and I are praying for you.
 
User Mood
Worried

Message Emote
blank
March 1, 2008, 5:24 pm PST

love

Quote From: mommyy

hello, I am a mom who has a daughter with an eating disorder.  She came to us for help over 1 year ago.  Although I suspected something it all began very slowly.  My daughter is a binger.  It was a long process and a very painful one for the entire family.  We had to bring her to emergency as we found her in her room curled up in the closet in the fetal position.  This is my third child.  A top student in school.  One that we told we love you all the time to.  But something happened.  We still don't know what triggered this.  But from a little girl she was obsessive compulsive.  Very strong willed,  Anyways long story short.  Over this last year, she has hurt me very much,  Verbally abusive to the point where I can not be in the same room with her.  I am so sad I know she has a problem, but it has also drained us as a family, so you have have not gone through a situation can be very critical of this mother and say its not about you , can't you see that your daughter is in pain, but there is a point where after a year of it, i am drained and can not cope and maybe that mother could not either.  So maybe you can appreciate the other side of this situation. 

 

When my husband and I try to hug our daughter (she is 17) she pushes us away, We tell her we love her, but she ignores this.  She leaves for school in the am.  Comes home from school,  will take her food to her room and eat there,  Will Not eat with us, It is very painful to see this.  We realize that it is the disease, but boy does it hurts,  Therapy is currently on hold as she has convinced the doctors that she no longer has a problem. 

As a parent with a daughter currently in treatment, i have and  am going through the same emotions. The only thing i can share with you is that at 12 or 17, they can't with hold your paycheck or tell you what you can't do, they only way they can hurt you is to withhold their love.  This is there way of  sharing some of the pain they feel.  There "mask" is a very hard exterior, when inside they are crying inside.  Please hear what she is not saying and hang in their.  Firm but gentle hand can go a long way.  With anyone who has any experience with this "monster"  knows the first step is admission, and its' a very long long road.  I tell myself, when i think i can't take anymore, of the attitude, lies, or deceipt, try to remember your daughter is there, but those walls she put up weren't built in a day and they can take what seems forever to tear down.  Please hang in there, and good luck!
 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
March 16, 2008, 5:26 am PDT

11/16 Scary Skinny

Quote From: jenniferc1

As a parent with a daughter currently in treatment, i have and  am going through the same emotions. The only thing i can share with you is that at 12 or 17, they can't with hold your paycheck or tell you what you can't do, they only way they can hurt you is to withhold their love.  This is there way of  sharing some of the pain they feel.  There "mask" is a very hard exterior, when inside they are crying inside.  Please hear what she is not saying and hang in their.  Firm but gentle hand can go a long way.  With anyone who has any experience with this "monster"  knows the first step is admission, and its' a very long long road.  I tell myself, when i think i can't take anymore, of the attitude, lies, or deceipt, try to remember your daughter is there, but those walls she put up weren't built in a day and they can take what seems forever to tear down.  Please hang in there, and good luck!

I agree that OCEANFRONT4U is judgmental and selfrighteous and should be sentenced to the Dr. Phil house for 30 days to live with and BE RESPONSIBILE for a teenage anorexic.

 

 I agree with JenniferC and Mommyv..... I wouldn't sit on stage either with my daughter, but probably mostly related to the viscious lies she tells to protect her anorexia that are directed at you the parent who is doing everything and sacrificing to make her better.  Research says that Anorexic parents are usually perfectionists which would suggest they are doing more for their child than the average parent.

 

WORD PICTURE:  Anorexia is like Cancer... like Leukemia.... it goes in periods of relapse and remission.  Now if someone had cancer themselves truly THEY would be seeking Treatment; where contrarily an Anorexic usually doesn't want treatment and SABOTAGES your sacrifices and efforts to help her which is very frustrating where you do daily have to forgive her and look beyond this and keep working for her recovery.  Now if a child had an ear infection you go to the Dr., get the medicine and they are all better and they are happy with you that you helped them get better.....  Whereas in anorexia YOU ARE THE ENEMY when you are trying to help them get better....  Anyone who gets in the way is the enemy.

 

I've noticed that it causes alot of division in families because they are trying to BLAME someone for it.... just like oceanfront4u seemed to.  YOU KNOW WHATEVER THE CAUSE(S)... I think the reality is:  It started somehow... AND EVERYDAY SOMEONE WITH THIS DISEASE WAKES UP THEY HAVE CHOICES TO MAKE.  They ultimately are the ones who have to make those daily choices to get better.  And although there may have been triggers.... ultimately They did it once, they did it again and again and again.. and have to take a little responsibilty....

 

but I agree with Jessica that eating police-ing SHOULDN'T BE the only thing you talk about to that child because it puts them on the defense and damages the relationship whereas as a parent thats your natural instinct to teach your child to do what is good for them..... but this is a daily challenge... because you daily have to watch your child be self destructive or find evidence of it that you thought was cured and  it breaks your heart into a 1,000 pieces.

 

 

 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
March 17, 2008, 5:53 am PDT

11/16 Scary Skinny

In defense of Susan (Mom):  I had a counsellour shake her head and criticize me because I didn't "cry" also in a meeting when my daughter was crying because "she had to be  at a counselling meeting."  I don't feel the counsellour appreciated all the effort it took just to get her there.  I have done so many things for her. It's a tug of war... They don't just say ok great I am going or OK I'll go.... They say NO, I am not going, there is nothing wrong with me... you are the worst mother in the world and then think of lies to punish you and get you back.  I think you are hearing the story for the 1st time and some of us have been dealing with it for years.  I have shed many wailing tears, but you can't live in that mode  all the time.  Perhaps for the sake of  TV you wanted to hear the initial wailing which I KNOW HAPPENED MANY A TIMES in every situation.... but you go thru the grief process and are at different levels and accept things to some degree and lose a little hope.  This weekend I had to tug of war with my daughter to get her blood drawn.  I HAD TO PAY HER $10 to cooperate and I was the worst mother in the world, but I was like look IF you were in a foster home you would have to get your blood drawn and do whatever the Dr. says and there would be no negociation and they wouldn't pay you $10 ok?   And the $10 pacified her.... but ? Average parent:  Do you pay your kid to cooperate with medical treatment?   but today is a New day: St. Patty's Day and I bought her St. Patty's Day socks and shamrock light up necklace to wear to school.  We are going to plant  Spring flower seeds in a 72 pack Walmart soil kit greenhouse if she is in  good mood after school.... but these are the little things I do.....

 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
happy
June 7, 2008, 10:48 am PDT

DoctorPhil Show.

Doctor Phil Scary Skinny. I would be afraid if I was skinny myself or anyone else. Beside I donot think that--

anyone would be affraid to be skinny at all. See you on Wednesday June 11th, 2008. Sincerley Your. Rus--

sell Vlaanderen.-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
chillin'
June 9, 2008, 1:52 pm PDT

Former Guests

Dr. Phil had a show similar to this a couple of years ago. One of the Ladies that was portrayed lives in my area. I have forgotten her name, but, it was something unusual, like Joey. I used to see this woman just about everyday, walking, with a limp, all over town. She was very, very underweight. Her skin was just hanging off her body. She ate nothing but popcorn, drank water, and exercised all day. Her sister was on the show with her. I believe her sister was her twin.

I used to see her shopping in our local Wal Mart Super Center, walking up and down the aisles. She never had much food in her basket, but would pick up cans and boxes, read the labels, and put the item back on the shelf.

Dr. Phil offered her help, but she refused it.

Now I don't see her any more. Not walking. Not shopping.

I was just wondering if the shows staff can enlighten me and let me know if she is still alive?

 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
June 10, 2008, 12:10 pm PDT

06/11 Scary Skinny

Quote From: lvacffeshp

In defense of Susan (Mom):  I had a counsellour shake her head and criticize me because I didn't "cry" also in a meeting when my daughter was crying because "she had to be  at a counselling meeting."  I don't feel the counsellour appreciated all the effort it took just to get her there.  I have done so many things for her. It's a tug of war... They don't just say ok great I am going or OK I'll go.... They say NO, I am not going, there is nothing wrong with me... you are the worst mother in the world and then think of lies to punish you and get you back.  I think you are hearing the story for the 1st time and some of us have been dealing with it for years.  I have shed many wailing tears, but you can't live in that mode  all the time.  Perhaps for the sake of  TV you wanted to hear the initial wailing which I KNOW HAPPENED MANY A TIMES in every situation.... but you go thru the grief process and are at different levels and accept things to some degree and lose a little hope.  This weekend I had to tug of war with my daughter to get her blood drawn.  I HAD TO PAY HER $10 to cooperate and I was the worst mother in the world, but I was like look IF you were in a foster home you would have to get your blood drawn and do whatever the Dr. says and there would be no negociation and they wouldn't pay you $10 ok?   And the $10 pacified her.... but ? Average parent:  Do you pay your kid to cooperate with medical treatment?   but today is a New day: St. Patty's Day and I bought her St. Patty's Day socks and shamrock light up necklace to wear to school.  We are going to plant  Spring flower seeds in a 72 pack Walmart soil kit greenhouse if she is in  good mood after school.... but these are the little things I do.....

 

If your daughter is "crying" because she isn't getting her way, such as going to counseling when she doesn't want to, I don't see any sense in "crying" along with her. Wouldn't that be counter-productive? Not too sure that "counselor" would be much "help" to your daughter, anyway. Getting onto you for not crying? Seems rather unprofessional to me. Shouldn't she have asked your daughter why she was crying? The counselor could've used the "reason" for your daughter's "tears" to assess her "readiness" for treatment.
 
User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
blank
June 10, 2008, 12:14 pm PDT

06/11 Scary Skinny

I couldn't believe how much Alita's stomach could stretch out from all that Chinese food. And, return to its original wash-board flatness after she purged in the bathroom. No telling how much damage she's already done to her esophagus from all that purging.
 
User Mood
Depressed

Message Emote
blank
June 11, 2008, 10:13 am PDT

06/11 Scary Skinny

You know the sad thing about these women with anorexia and bulemia is that I wish I had their will power.  I wish I was as strong in their convictions as they are.  I guess its pretty sad of me to envy them?
 
First | Prev | 27 | 28 | 29 | 30 | 31 | 32 | 33 | 34 | 35 | 36 | Next | Last