Message Boards

Topic : 07/17 Living on a Prayer

Number of Replies: 986
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, February 08, 2008, 12:25:06 pm
Author : DrPhilBoard1
(Original Air Date: 02/15/08) What happens when a parent’s agenda becomes so extreme that his or her children are forced to live a harsh, stoic existence? Dan and Janna are a college-educated couple married for 15 years with seven children, ages ranging from 2 weeks to 14. They have no income, no heat, no running water and are about to lose their house. Dan and Janna believe that their primitive lifestyle is God’s will, and that they are being led by the Lord. Janna’s mom, Carol, and stepdad, Rich, are worried about the health of their grandchildren. Are they eating enough? Are they warm enough? They say because the children are home schooled, they live in a cult-like home environment, and are not exposed to the outside world. Carol and Rich are willing to bail this family out one last time, but why are Dan and Janna refusing the help? After eight failed businesses, why won’t Dan get a job to support his family? Where will they go when they are forced out of their home? Talk about the show here.

Find out what happened on the show.

As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Apathetic

Message Emote
quiet
February 15, 2008, 8:44 am PST

Perspective

Just a little perspective.   Dr. Phil tries to help people with problems.  Therefore all the shows show people who have problems.  If you base life on doctor phil episodes, than you should never get married, because there is fighting,cheating, lieing and abuse. Everyone has eating problems, people are either to large to leave the house, or dieing from starvation, Con men are everywhere, and it is impossible to take pain killers without abusing them and becoming a drug addict.  So those of you who are worried that homeschooling is being given a bad name calm down.  People who are on his show typically take something meant for good, (food, medication, relationships,) and add their own unhealthy twist.  Do you really care what someone thinks if they base their entire view of homeschooling on one Dr. Phil Episode.  In life people will always warp good things.  I mean this in no way against the show.  It is doing a great job helping people.  But there are people out there that watch the show and catagorize people by what they see. These same type people, also make judgements solely on what is on the news.  I'm kind of going off now, but hope to get back to the point.  After the hurricaine, there were people who were wonderful and just wanted to help, there were people who had opinions based on what they heard, but really just wanted to understand, and were willing to listen to find out why someting that was being broadcasted on the news wasn't really accurrate. They listened to what you had to say before making  up their mind.  Then there were the people that took everything the news said as God.  I swear they could sniff me out, so they could bash Fema, or Nagin.  In "support of me"  if I had given those peope my energy I'd be dead,  They were the ones who were the most "far off".  In a disscussion I found myself in with someone who was ripping Nagin up one side and down the other, and me trying to defend him and trying to figure out how to gracefully escape, the lady looked my straight in the face, and asked me if he was smart?  In this she meant "learned". My brain nearly exploded trying to grasp the obserdity of the question. My point is in every facite of life those people are going to be there when you do anything, that they see as outside the realm of norm.  Though I believe in there own little world they mean well,  Don't waste your energy (fight) on them, it will only make you tired.

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
February 15, 2008, 8:47 am PST

I don't agree

Quote From: yoadrienne

They are looney.

 

And you know, God did not write the bible. I dont get where people take bits and pieces of text and make it fit in thier lives.  I have the feeling that Janna is about thisclose to saying..."Dan, you are an idiot and I'm kicking you to the curb"

Did you take a moment dear viewer to look fully into the face of his wife?  I did.  Her face is soft, no frown lines...no premature wrinkling, just soft and gentle eyes held on her man that God lead her to, no stress even though to Dr. Phil's audience, she was a living with a mad man...their children playing and happy, did you see him a playing with his kids?  I would have done just about anything had my dad taken the time to have spent it with us 9 kids.  He didn't work was all that he knew and alcohol when he finally made it to the top.

 

Long story short...money, alcohol without God in his life...lead him back towards the road that he raised the largest portion of us nine kids...no where land...

 

This is a Christian father/family that is being taken down here...not a dead beat father...

 

I for one am one Christian minister that believes that God is a leading all that want to be lead...and yes sometimes in the mist of our being lead...others that we are a depending on...fall by the way side of what they should have done...to have insured that our union was all within God's Will for all involved...

 

Meaning:  Sometimes that which is presented to us large business or dream weaver...both are being tested...."that which one does to the lowest of my children, he does to Me."

 

Just like a marriage takes two persons to hold it together...in a business relationship...it takes the Chief and the Indians a working together to bring all into harmony and balance.

 

This man didn't get a chance to state how his million dollar gross business went a bunk...

 

I personally would like for this guy to work with some sort of Eco group that are working on ways to live more harmonious, for you might be looking at the next billionaire...family.  His ideas aren't all that brain less...many like tropical fish and exotic plants a growing and a surving in conditions not native to their habitat.

 

Just because this man's dream doesn't fit the mold of what others would call real...they are never less, his dreams.

 

You have yours and I have mine.  Some people get luckier than others when someone walks into their world and says to them...I believe in you and I can help you obtain that which your dreaming is also my same dream.

 

This man hasn't found that yet.

 

I read a long time ago that in Our Bible, someone counted all the times that giving to others was better than receiving...and the amount of times although I never took the time to count them myself, outweigh all the scripture count of extending love to others.  Now I find that pretty profound and when I look at all the celebrities that give willingly to others and watch how they fortune just keeps on a growing...I have to believe that there is some validity in what I read several years again.

 

I am a giver...I have found that by giving to others, if nothing more than support...helps me always in the long run...

 

I believe like Dr. Phil that money is a necessary evil...I really don't believe that this man didn't want to work...for he states that he is a workaholic...if nothing more than a working his mind...deciding how he could have changed the invention to make it more amendable to everyone in the exercise industry instead of just one industry...

 

He to me is a man that ran out of resources...for he hasn't been a living without water and heat for that long and the churches do help those needy folks that have food and survival needs...so there are resources for him even if the government doesn't help...

 

So I don't think anyone should be a calling in Johhny Law to take away his kids...

 

I truthfully don't believe that his wife's parents wanted the outcome that they got...I believe that what they wanted was for someone to spot his uniqueness and contact him...for living simply is what I believe this whole country/perhaps world should be a heading towards...we are in grave trouble in America.

 

Jobs are what keeps the nation a floating in the heat of so much debt.

 

Just call me a dreamer.

May You Be Blessed

Love, Light and Peace

Tonie

 
User Mood
Worried

Message Emote
blank
February 15, 2008, 8:49 am PST

no appropriate words fit this

 I am a Christian.  I study scripture.  But more important is God loves me and I love him.  We all do dumb things when we are young trying to understand and love God and please Him.  However, part of this process is to learn and move closer, not to sit in your own mess.  Try reading the following scriptrue and please read the whole chapter, not just the verse below.

2 Thes. 3:10 (NIV)    

   For even when we were with you, we gave you this rule: "If a man will not work, he shall not eat."  


I have never found scripture to contradict itself when you read all of scripture but you can sure take a sentence here and there and make it seem contradictory.


  

It appears this guy is afraid of life because of some past failures or who knows what?  It sure seems like this fellow has allowed life experiences to make him afraid rather than creative.   Then he hides behind the scriptures and his ''belief''  that this is what God is saying to him.  Seems to contradict the above scripture.
Has he put his fears in a place of more importance than taking care of his children? Not a father I would like to have.
 


Are his wife's actions, although she appears to be more level headed than him, making her an accomplice,.  Where is her backbone?  She is a human being with a good mind, after all.  I do believe in submission but do you submit to someone who does not know and follow God's actual scripture rather than what he wants scripture to say.. 

  

To this father, I feel the problem is not money, it is your mind. Please get some help.
  



  


  


 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
February 15, 2008, 8:52 am PST

Home Schooling

Quote From: grandmal6

what kind of church do they go to? they need to talk to the pastor of their church to get some guides and some kind of  counseling. their older ghildren should be in a public school to make friends.. i thought all the chidren looked real healthy and happy. the bible  says in 1 timothy 5:8 says we are to provide for our family. i hope that he can find a job. for he has alot of mouth to feed. they must be getting some kind of help from somewhere. where is his mom and dad. and what are they saying about this . i will be praying for the family. godbles the little children. jesus said let the little children come  unto me. for he said that we have to come to him as alittle child. god bless sue

The stats comparing home schooled children to those in public schools is rather alarming in comparison...

 

I now wish that I could have been able to have stayed home with my kids instead of working...for those that are home schooled are the achievers in colleges and universities...

 

Simply due perhaps to more bonding time allocated them and more personalized attention to their individual needs and specialness...

 

Instead of being placed in the same box as everyone else...

 

So I disagree with their need for more socialized time...yet that is my opinion and we all our own...

 

May You Be Blessed

Love, Light and Peace

Tonie

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
sad
February 15, 2008, 8:55 am PST

Living on a Prayer

Parents - One of you needs to grow up, face your responsibilities as a parent and get a job.  What kind of role models do you thing you are giving your children?  They deserve to live in an environment where they feel safe and happy.  My heart really breaks for the baby.  None of these kids asked to be  put into this "lifestyle".  Use your college educations and get work - Dan obviously you could work in landscaping since you seem to be so gifted with growing things or perhaps you could work in a pet store.  Break some sweat, and get a job!

 

Grandparents - Stop giving them money!  This is only enabling them!  Further, if you have not thought about it, make sure your wills are up to date.  If  you are wanting to leave anything behind, make a trust fund for the children and appoint someone to be the guardian of that trust fund for them...not their mother or father!

 

Leave God out of this.  He gave you life, he died for you and all  your sins.  Show Him some respect.

 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
February 15, 2008, 8:59 am PST

Thank you for caring enough to add your voice

Quote From: tikker12

Just a little perspective.   Dr. Phil tries to help people with problems.  Therefore all the shows show people who have problems.  If you base life on doctor phil episodes, than you should never get married, because there is fighting,cheating, lieing and abuse. Everyone has eating problems, people are either to large to leave the house, or dieing from starvation, Con men are everywhere, and it is impossible to take pain killers without abusing them and becoming a drug addict.  So those of you who are worried that homeschooling is being given a bad name calm down.  People who are on his show typically take something meant for good, (food, medication, relationships,) and add their own unhealthy twist.  Do you really care what someone thinks if they base their entire view of homeschooling on one Dr. Phil Episode.  In life people will always warp good things.  I mean this in no way against the show.  It is doing a great job helping people.  But there are people out there that watch the show and catagorize people by what they see. These same type people, also make judgements solely on what is on the news.  I'm kind of going off now, but hope to get back to the point.  After the hurricaine, there were people who were wonderful and just wanted to help, there were people who had opinions based on what they heard, but really just wanted to understand, and were willing to listen to find out why someting that was being broadcasted on the news wasn't really accurrate. They listened to what you had to say before making  up their mind.  Then there were the people that took everything the news said as God.  I swear they could sniff me out, so they could bash Fema, or Nagin.  In "support of me"  if I had given those peope my energy I'd be dead,  They were the ones who were the most "far off".  In a disscussion I found myself in with someone who was ripping Nagin up one side and down the other, and me trying to defend him and trying to figure out how to gracefully escape, the lady looked my straight in the face, and asked me if he was smart?  In this she meant "learned". My brain nearly exploded trying to grasp the obserdity of the question. My point is in every facite of life those people are going to be there when you do anything, that they see as outside the realm of norm.  Though I believe in there own little world they mean well,  Don't waste your energy (fight) on them, it will only make you tired.

I know what you are a saying...sometimes it does take lots of energy to get my truths out, especially since I too have walked such similar paths with many on Dr. Phil's show...

 

I just feel that if I don't...perhaps people like the ones we just watched...will leave the show and start to believe all that others a watching their brief summation of their lives, have a better handle on them, than they do...sometimes the viewers are right, yet most of the time...those that can't think or see outside of the box of the obvious...go off on them...not helping only a hurting them...

 

I feel that God would have me help all caught in the same dilemma...not many in my life took up for me and I found myself a fighting everything myself with God's help, only...

 

Just my thoughts

Your words have made me tear up...I thank you.  Tears can be helpful...you know?  Thank you for caring enough to give us your very best as well...

 

Love, Light and Peace

Tonie

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
February 15, 2008, 9:00 am PST

Anyone see Rebeling and Enabling?

I see two adults using their children to exort money from their parents. I see 2 sets of parents of adult children falling for it, thus enabling the whole situation.  That guy is a lazy foolish dreamer and his wife is rebelling and lazy. Of course she keeps having kids,, she doesn't have to go out in the real world and work. Of course she supports his dreamer ways she has an excuse for the poor conditions in which her children live and can you say childish rebellion of her controling Mother? That situation is a hot mess of selfish behavior on both sides. The parents shelling out the money are getting a self serving thrill when they give the money. The adult children are using their parents concern for the children to keep from facing the reality that the guy is a lazy dreaming fool. How can I say this? I have a daughter who was in a similar situation. She was constantly having "bad luck", making "unfortunate choices". For quite a while I was only too happy to come to her rescue. I felt so important.  After several years of my doing without in order to help her, my light bulb went off. I realized the more I critisized her choices the more she was going to defend them. I realized that every time I gave her money I was actually telling her she would never be able to figure out her issues on her own. When my light bulb lit, I told my daughter that I would no longer hand her money to solve her problems. I told her I thought she was smart enough to find her own solution. I explained to her that I felt it was selfish of me to deprive her of opportunities to develope her character, wisdom and knowledge.  I also told her that if I ever felt her child was being abused or mistreated in any way because of her "unfortunate choices" I would take her to court and petition for custody.  She struggles, makes mistakes but is making her way in the world. I worry,, silently. I keep my opinions to myself, even if she asks for them. I listen to her and always answer this way," You are smart, I love you, I am sure you will figure your problem out". She is never going to make the same choices I would which is fine with me as long as she is moving forward and making a life for herself and her son. The moral of my story is there is never just one side to a situation. The parents are not making mistakes, the adult children are making mistakes. The innocent children are suffering.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
February 15, 2008, 9:08 am PST

Dear One

Quote From: mickey310

 I am a Christian.  I study scripture.  But more important is God loves me and I love him.  We all do dumb things when we are young trying to understand and love God and please Him.  However, part of this process is to learn and move closer, not to sit in your own mess.  Try reading the following scriptrue and please read the whole chapter, not just the verse below.

2 Thes. 3:10 (NIV)    

   For even when we were with you, we gave you this rule: "If a man will not work, he shall not eat."  


I have never found scripture to contradict itself when you read all of scripture but you can sure take a sentence here and there and make it seem contradictory.


  

It appears this guy is afraid of life because of some past failures or who knows what?  It sure seems like this fellow has allowed life experiences to make him afraid rather than creative.   Then he hides behind the scriptures and his ''belief''  that this is what God is saying to him.  Seems to contradict the above scripture.
Has he put his fears in a place of more importance than taking care of his children? Not a father I would like to have.
 


Are his wife's actions, although she appears to be more level headed than him, making her an accomplice,.  Where is her backbone?  She is a human being with a good mind, after all.  I do believe in submission but do you submit to someone who does not know and follow God's actual scripture rather than what he wants scripture to say.. 

  

To this father, I feel the problem is not money, it is your mind. Please get some help.
  



  


  


Again, did you not hear that the wife stated that he has four or five job applications out there and is waiting for the call back?

 

I can't remember the name of one of the authors that Oprah had on her show that wrote a book about being in the interim of life...a time and place where nothing real was being manifested...sort of like sitting at the bottom of the hole one has dug for themselves, deciding that the only way out of that hole was up...he will get up and when he does, I do hope that Dr. Phil will be a bringing him back on the show with his lovely family for all things do happen for a reason...all things...

 

I have that much faith, trust and belief that God never allows His children to fall that far from Him...gentle, caring and loving Arms...

 

Some one will spot the needs of this man and his family...just like the person that wrote on this site about all the help that God sends us and how it is up to us to decide which is valuable and which is not...what is valuable to me is the fact that in the Bible...women are to follow the lead of their Christian lead spouse...this wife is not an enabler...she is doing what God has lead her to do...if that means into a hole for a while...so be it.

 

Personally to me, when I was in love with my significant other, I would have lived in a cave just to be with him...I believe that Dr. Phil's Robin...would agree.

 

Those are my thoughts for whatever they are worth...

Love, Light and Peace

May You Be Blessed

Tonie

 
User Mood
Relaxed

Message Emote
blank
February 15, 2008, 9:16 am PST

Dan - It's Not All About You!

Dan - Wake up.  Life isn't all about you, what your dreams are, what kind of job you want, etc.  You have a very poor knowledge of scripture.  The Apostle Paul took great pains to not be a burden to others.  He worked making tents.  If the Apostle Paul was not too important to do menial labor such as making tents, then why are you absolved?  Or what about Jesus who was a carpenter?  If he was a carpenter he obviously spent time making things with and doing work.  And, his life was poured out for others not spent doing exactly what he wanted to do whenever he felt like it. 

  So, sorry Dan.  You need to look in the mirror.  You are completely selfish and self-absorbed.  You are not providing for your family because you simply choose not too!  You wife loves you and wants to support you.  However, you are completely WRONG.  So, the end result of your selfishness is that your wife will eventually leave with the children and/or the children will be taken away from you because of your living conditions.

  If you truly love and care for your family, you will go out and work and earn income.  And, sorry, you don't even have to "like" your job in anyway.  If you can earn money cleaning sewers, picking up trash, scrubbing floors, then that is what you should be doing.  I highly respect anyone who works in ANY job doing their work.  So, stop deluding yourseld and telling us how "hard working" you are.  That is pure nonsense.  Your sin is staring you in the face - the sin of laziness.  However, you are defiant and I saw no inkling that you are even willing to hear.  He who has ears to ear, let him hear.    

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
upset
February 15, 2008, 9:21 am PST

Blaming God

It truly galls me when someone who alleges to be a Christian blames God for everything. This man needs to stop making children, get off his duff and find a job and re-read his bible. There's a scripture that says "if a man does not work neither does he eat". I wonder if he's ever read that verse. Sometimes God allows us to stew in our own mess. God gives us free will, he will not force anyone to do anything. This family truly needs counseling and work ethics to boot.
 
First | Prev | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | Next | Last