Topic : 06/06 "I'm Gay, OK?"

Number of Replies: 4125
New Messages This Week: 0
Last Reply On:
Created on : Friday, October 14, 2005, 03:56:41 pm
Author : DrPhilBoard1

(Original Air Date: 10/19/05) Sexual orientation used to be something kept hidden from family and co-workers, but now more and more people are "coming out" and finding acceptance. Anjela says her mother and sister don't support her sexual orientation, and feel she can't be Christian and gay at the same time. Can they reconcile this touchy issue? Then, two men debate whether a person can go from gay to straight, and parents of a 4-year-old boy fear their son's desire to play with dolls and wear heels means he'll grow up to be gay. Are they overreacting to his wishes to be a princess instead of a prince? Talk about gender and gay issues here.


Find out what happened on the show.

 

More June 2006 Show Boards.


As of January, 2009, this message board will become "Read Only" and will be closed to further posting. Please join the NEW Dr. Phil Community to continue your discussions, personalize your message board experience, start a blog and meet new friends.

User Mood
Mellow

Message Emote
anxious
October 19, 2005, 3:41 pm PDT

About the 4 yearold boy who wears heels.........

  

At the age of three, my grandson loved to wear my high heels, silky fabrics, and loved anything pink.  He prefered playing with little girls, and loved all girl toys.  "Boy" toys had NO interest for him.   

  

He is now five and a half, and nothilng has changed.  He had his first bad experience this year in kindergarten.  He earned a "prize"  and was given his choice of items in a Treasure Box.  He chose a small doll with a pnk dress.  The other boys made fun of him, and he was very upset. 

  

On the program today, Dr. Phil advised the parent of the 4 year old to relax and let him know if the situation does not change in six month.   

  

How does my daughter go about finding the "right" therapist for this problem?  They live in Jacksonville, FL, and there are some resources, but how does one go about finding an appropriate one? 

  

Help!!! 

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 19, 2005, 3:41 pm PDT

From a Gay Christian

As a faithful Christian active in my church, and the gay son of a retired Southern Baptist minister, I find many of the comments on this topic disturbingly hateful. My God is loving and welcoming, not feared and exclusionary. Too bad many of you don't have the same one--you're missing out! 

  

I grew up in the south where many residents seem to have the same negative attitudes about homosexuality that I've read here; however, many of them--as well as many of you--have gay friends and relatives who are closeted out of fear, or are ignored, frowned-upon, forgotten, or otherwise overlooked. (I think of the gay brother of a prominent business man in the church where my dad was pastor when I was in high school. You would think he'd be targeted for bashing, but people "overlook" it because he is seen as good person in an influential family.)  

  

I am a responsible Christian man, a loving son, faithful brother, favorite uncle, loyal friend, successful business man. respected alumnus of a prestigeous college, and a competitive athlete. My sexuality isn't an issue in these relationships or settings, nor should it be--but because of hateful and closed-minded people, I will remain to be publicly closeted. I do that out of respect for my dad and to deflect attention from myself, because of his prominence in our area and the perceived negativity given to being gay by many people. Also, I'm in a very quiet relationship with someone who is known in athletics in our area, and that would be a career killer for him. 

  

I'm sure many will discount it, but for the viewpoint of a minister, read Rev. Bruce W. Lowe's "Letter to Louise" regarding how the Bible really treats homosexuality. I found the website and letter by wandering around the internet a few years ago. Click on http://www.godmademegay.com/ and then on the link "Read the Letter." I hope it is an eye-opener for many of you. 

  

I'm thankful my dad had a ministry based on healing, love, and service to the Lord. He didn't hate me because of my sexuality, but loved me as his son who also shares his genetics and his name.  

  

There are many more thoughts in my head, but I'll close with this: God is Love. Remember that. 

  

 
User Mood
Cheerful

Message Emote
blank
October 19, 2005, 3:42 pm PDT

Cross Dressing

Quote From: keyson

An age old question: Is this something that I do or something that I am? I feel that I have some special insight. I recall being dressed as a girl when I was either kindergarten or before. I am now a 53 year old male and have always had an attraction towards cross-dressing. I have struggled with this question over the years. In one sense, I have always felt the need to express the "woman inside". At the end of the day, however, I usually conclude that this is something I "do". I believe, though, that the feelings towards this are very similar to homosexuality. There is the need to do this and the everpresent question of whether it is behavior or identity. I believe strongly that it is "not of God", and that I have been guitly, over the years, of compartmentalizing my life, that is, this for God and this for my ego.  

I tend to think it is the same for gays. 

 It is kinda like the children raised with parents that smoke - they want to be grown up like their parents and smoke too.  Same with drinking.  Once we realize that something is not right or can hurt us,  it is a choice that we have to stop or get help in stopping.  I personally believe calling out to God for help is the best.  Alot of counselors today are in it for the money and create a bigger problem for the MONEY.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 19, 2005, 3:42 pm PDT

I aggree with the bible

Quote From: ykz_pilot

It's too bad you don't put more emphasis on what God says on the subject, instead of homosexual propoganda.  If you reject the Bible, and what Jesus taught, then fine.  Do what you will, but to claim to be a Christian and reject the teachings of Jesus because you want to continue to live a life of sin is hypocrisy. 

  

Jesus spoke often on the family.  Always in the context of a man and a woman.  Always enforced this monogamy for life.  He spoke often about the perversions of sex (outside of marriage) and the God ordained marriage not the farce done in the name of He who called homosexuality a perversion.   

  

Throughout scripture New Testament and the Original Testament ... homosexuality is condemned and since God is the same yesterday today, and forever - it always will be to those who are Godly people. 

  

Many people live perverted sexual lives.  Premarital sex is just as evil as homosexual sex or beasiality or pedophelia.  They are equally harmful and outside of God's plan for His children.  Of course you don't hear single people claiming people who disagree with their choices are "forniphobic".  The reason people made up the meaningless term homophobic is because they don't want people to disagree with them.  It is sheer politics.  Claiming a lie does not make truth. 

  

Look at the many people who have conquered the sexual addiction of homosexuality.  Look at Dack Rambo, the actor.  He was saved, and after experiencing a relationship with Jesus, he repented of his homosexual choices (his words), started "Dack Rambo Ministries" in an effort to help people out of the bondage of homosexuality.  He died of AIDS, but he is now in Glory.  Not because he was a good person, but because he was born from above, and he repented of his sin.  He is a true role model for people caught in the homosexual bondage.  Also, look to other organizations that free people, and are run by ex-homosexuals.  Look to "Love Won Out" and Exodus International.   

  

God loves all men, and all women.  Those who claim to love Him but reject His teaching are, as scripture said, liars.  He doesn't ask you to be perfect.  He asks you to "go and sin no more".  And most importantly ... scrpture is clear that if you CONDONE sin, that you are guilty of it yourself.  So all those people who say that a woman has the right to choose to kill her baby, they are guilty of killing that baby themselves.  There are no sidelines to stand on.   

  

Those who think you can be a "non-practicing" homosexual are misled.  Your temptations do NOT define who you are.  If that were the case then almost every man on the planet would have to call himself a non-practicing adulterer or non-practicing fornicator, or non-practicing rapist.  Nonsense. 

  

God calls His children to Holiness.  Not pervertedness.  

  

   

Hey, you are absolutly wright. Today so many people believe that if it feels wright then do it. We have the liberals in this country to thank for that. The futher we stray from God the more we as a nation will suffer from his rath. People just don't understand the consiquinces of their sins and what impact it has on the rest of us.  I 'am not perfact , and I do sin, but I know right from wrong. Being gay is very. wrong. I was surprised that Dr. Phill didn't say tha t," homosexuality  is genetic, because in a previous show he said," you are born that Way." I was very upset when he said that. He is pressured by Hollywood, I'am sure. If he said anything agianst gays, his show would be off the air in a heartbeat. I would  like  to see him do a show on partial birth abortion. This clearly is murder! and anyone who disagrees needs their heads examined.  I believe that the people that came up with this procedure and convinced many people that this was not muder, but merely a choice, could also come up with a "procedure , that once the baby was born full turm, delivered naturally, then kill it by whatever means it would take and call it abortion." People in this country would believe that this was not Murder , but just a choice by a woman. How sad we have become as humans. God have mercy on us.
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 19, 2005, 3:44 pm PDT

10/19 "I'm Gay, OK?"

Quote From: proud2bmom

First, I am a Christian and I realize that some people will label me "a right winger" that is unwilling to accept people who disagree with the views of my religion.  However, I know that I stand for what the bible says and I will express my views.  

To those who say that the bible does not reject homosexuality, I say this: Read the bible! As has been pointed out by others, Leviticus rejects this act. Also, in the New Testament, 1 Corinthians 6:9 says, "Do you not know that the unrighteous will not inherit the kingdom of God? Do not be deceived. Neither fornicators, nor idolaters, nor adulterers, nor homosexuals [in some versions, catamites, nor sodomites, nor thieves, ... will inherit the kingdom of God."  I think that is pretty clear.  Sinners that do not repent of these sins will not make it to heaven. People think that once we accept Jesus as our Savior we just go on with our lives and continue to sin since we are saved by grace.  Grace is a gift from God, but we need to live our lives in an appreciative way.  I am a sinner saved by grace, just like everyone else.  The difference?  I acknowledge my sin and try to change my life. We can't continue to live in sin without repenting.  

We were made from the begginning as man and woman. It is not natural for a person to be with someone of the same sex.  Look at  it logically, two men or two women cannot reproduce. If our society were made up of homosexuals, we would die off immediately. The perfect and correct way is the way that God made us. One man with one woman!  

Do I hate homosexuals? No, but I do find it offensive that society is pressuring me to accept homosexuals, yet at the same time, pushing to sweep my faith and values under the carpet to make room for a generation of "values".  Where has this gotten us? We have more STD's than ever before, diseases such as HIV and AIDS have become wide spread, and quite frankly our society is deteriorating. No, I don't blame this on just homosexuality. I blame it on the inability of our society to set down a strict line between right and wrong, and the lack of self-control and responsibility that people show.  

I do not judge these people. My job as a Christian is to show them the word of God and try to be an example. God will be the ultimate judge! For now, I will continue to pray that our society will change for the better!  

Think about it people! 

Thank you my friend, you are right on the money! I too am tired of being pushed to accept the gay lifestyle. I am sick of having to turn my t.v. off just because of a gay on there saying I matter so deal with it! Yeah they matter as a person, but their lifestyle needs to be their business and leave all of us who fear the Lord out of it. I will do whatever I have to just to try and rehabilitate whoever is interested, and pray for those who aren't. I will never accept it because God's words are true and when left my sins at the cross I promised God to obey him and live by his word, and as long as I am alive I will never stop speaking God's word no matter how I am labeled. After all God warned we Christian's would not be accepted. But I do know I will stand before him in time and I have no worries about him turning away from me.
 
User Mood
Worried

Message Emote
blank
October 19, 2005, 3:44 pm PDT

is everyone forgetting something?

Do any of you christians research the history behind the bible? I've read up on it a little. A lot of the stories came from other religions before christians came along. A prime example would be Noah's Arc. This story has been found in many ancient cultures including the super-pagan ancient egyptians. ALSO most of the things condemned at the time were because of the spread of diseases and a cultural need to stop killing each other through sex and food. I think people should do some research on what their defending until they put on the holy hat.
 
User Mood
Angry

Message Emote
blank
October 19, 2005, 3:44 pm PDT

Oh, again with the scripture... please.

Quote From: snowryder

You would think that the only people with hate according to you are those who have a religious background. Your hate toward religion may have some justification, however, I don't remember reading where Jesus came to create a religion. Religion pure and simple is man's ways of trying to appease God. Yet in the life of Jesus we see God's way of reaching man. What was Jesus' first message? "Repent for the kingdom of heaven is at hand." That message was to all of us whether heterosexual or homosexual. The Bible is clear that there are many heterosexual relationships that are wrong. Adultery and fornication are sins that can affect those who are heterosexual. The only sexual relationship sanctioned by God is between one woman and one man in the marriage bond. Has marriage failed in America? NO! America has failed in marriage. Just because many marriages are failing does not mean marriage is not valid. The truth is, you can't find a shread of scripture that will support the homosexual lifestyle in the original languages. You can though find several scriptures that give strong warnings to those caught up in the sin of homosexuality. Romans 1: 26-28          1 Corinthians 6: 9-11 

The word effeminate is the key word to consider in the scripture. The great hope that is found in 1 Corinthians is found with the apostle Paul says in verse 11,  "And such were some of you." 

  

That was my point... religion is a man-made entity, not a making of Jesus Christ, and the Bible was written by one of these "holy" men, which is why it's subjective to that particular man's wants, needs, and desires, these religions where women are not worthy enough to speak.  He is the supposed interpreter of God.  Ever seen the episode of South Park called "All About Mormans"?  It is entirely relevant to my point.  It speaks so much truth about our world and it's blind, and in many cases, ignorant faith.  I'd be happy to send it to you. 

  

Who among us can say with certainty that is was the true word of God recorded by these men?  Religion can be too easy manipulated to the gain of it's so-called "spiritual" leader.  They don't want people to achieve an independent relationship with God because it means they will lose a little bit of their own power.  If the word of God is golden, then he makes no mistakes, and everything happens for a reason.  So who are you to pick homosexuality out as something other than a natural intention of God?  Forgive me for being skeptical of so many who have sinned more than I ever could. 

  

I have a spiritual relationship with God.  The God who loves all of his creations.  I don't need to rely on any specific religion to aide me in my journey; I've been there, tried that.  It made no sense when I thought about it with the logic and thought that God gave me.  I am very aware that hate comes in all forms, but as is seen on this thread, the majority of people opposing the validity of homosexuality is using religion as it's justification.  Immediately they pull out their bibles and start preaching passages... they have no other basis for their judgments other than what has been seared into their minds from religious men.  It is these religious men and their own sins and hypocrisy that have tainted the religious entities for me today.   I will not ignore the disgraceful behavior of these men in the name of God no matter how many times you recite your subjective view of the Bible. 

 
User Mood
Peaceful

Message Emote
blank
October 19, 2005, 3:46 pm PDT

10/19 "I'm Gay, OK?"

Quote From: irishmom

 The only problem I have with gay men is that they are GAY which means they are off limits to women like me (who is married anyway, but I wasn't always).  It's hard to find a nice guy in the world today, and it seems like when you do find them, you find out they're gay!  I had the biggest crush on this guy in high school just to find out he was gay.  I was crushed!  Oh well, such is life I guess.
Too funny!!  I had to laugh when I read this because when I sent my best friend a picture of my sons "friend" as he calls him..her comment was "all the cute ones are gay!"  Except for our husbands that is :o)
 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 19, 2005, 3:47 pm PDT

Alcoholism does NOT equal Homosexuality

Quote from the "slides" section related to the show: 

  

**Dr. Phil wants to distinguish between changing behavior and changing orientation. “You change the behavior, I don’t think anybody would disagree with that, but what you’re saying is, it shouldn’t be counted as a success if somebody goes and lives a life that is not their authentic self, but yet doesn’t practice a gay sexual relationship with somebody,” he says to Justin.

“There is a lot of pressure in ex-gay ministries to say that you’ve completely changed, whether or not that’s the case,” Justin points out.

David chimes in, “That is a complete misrepresentation of ex-gay ministries, in what we ask of people.”

“That’s why I’m always very skeptical of simply accepting anyone saying, ‘I used to be this, and now I am this,” Justin says.

“It is a struggle,” David admits. “It takes many years for the orientation to change. And there are times when people fail. But it’s just like alcoholism. It takes time, and you have to really want to change, or it’s not going to happen.”** 

  

David tried to call Justin a liar when he tried to claim that Justin had had contact with only one ex-gay ministry and/or was only using one as his source. Justin corrected that misunderstanding.  

  

In regard to alcoholism, and David himself, he was a drug and alcohol abuser. As a believer in Jesus the Christ, I personally know that God can and still does instantly heal people of alcoholism and drug addictions. But, God has NEVER changed a person's sexual orientation. Oh, it's possible that God can change sexual orientation; but, there has never been any real proof of that by any ex-gay. 

  

Andy Comiskey, founder of the ex-gay ministry "Desert Streams," which is in cahoots with Exodus International, wrote in the 1980s, that after he had been married more than 20 years and had grown children, he still experienced physiological sexual attraction towards men on occasion. Comiskey was calling himself an ex-homosexual and even claimed that God changed him; but, in that article in a conservative Christian magazine, Charisma, he said he admitted to a gay man what I just wrote when he found out the guy was gay and attending Comiskey's home church.  

 
User Mood
Happy

Message Emote
blank
October 19, 2005, 3:51 pm PDT

Anjela

Anjela this is for you if you read it.  I was sitting there watching the show and I couldn't help but see something that didn't get brought up.  You grew up a Christian believing that being gay was a sin and horrible.  You want your family to accept your lifestyle.  But, have you been able to accept yourself?  Do you worry that they are judging you and you are fighting for that not to happen because you yourself judged prior to your decision to be gay?  I ask because I became a Christian 16yrs ago and was very "legalistic".  When I came to know and understand God's grace it was difficult for me not to believe that my closest friends weren't/don't judge me on things that I use to judge others on.  The Bible does speak specifically to same sex orientation in the Old and New Testament.  God's word does not change.  We do.  I believe that your Mother and Sister love you tremendously but don't agree with your sexual orientation.  That does not mean they don't love you or accept you.  You need to allow them room to love you without jumping on and celebrating something they don't agree with.  Sometimes, you have to leave some issues alone.  If you need someone to talk to about your emotional problems with your different relationships, get a friend that can listen and advise you in your sexual orientation.  It is not fair to ask them to do this when they don't agree.  You don't want them to only allow a relationship with you if you are straight.  You shouldn't only demand a relationship  that makes them focus on your sexual orientation.  You can all have a wonderful, loving, caring and healthy relationship. 

Funny thing is I wanted to put a disclaimer in here that I am not saying as a Christian this is ok because I am wondering what other Christians will be thinking if they read this.  But, when it comes down to it, God is interested in a relationship with you and that should be the priority.  The Bible calls it sin, just like lieing is a sin.  God sees sin all the same.  We as humans place the levels on it.  We will all have to answer for our sin either before we die or when we are face to face with our maker.  Stop judging yourself and accept that your Mom and Sister are not judging you.   

Please read this with the heart it was intended.  I can be honest and sometimes miss the cushion words.  May God Bless you and your family and I hope you can find a way to be comfortable in your relationship with them. 

 
First | Prev | 36 | 37 | 38 | 39 | 40 | 41 | 42 | 43 | 44 | 45 | Next | Last